New cylinders

Which would you choose, and why?

  • Lycoming

    Votes: 12 75.0%

  • Millenium

    Votes: 2 12.5%

  • other

    Votes: 2 12.5%
  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .
Salty

Salty

Touchdown! Greaser!
PoA Supporter
Joined
Dec 21, 2016
Messages
14,264
Location
FL
Display Name
Display name:
Salty
So, I've decided to put all new cylinders on my O-360 for it's overhaul. The old ones are ok, but the cost difference between overhaul and all new is close enough I'd rather reset them all now during overhaul.

Cost difference is roughly $800 cheaper for the millenniums (about $200 per cylinder).
 
I've had good service from my Cessna's Millenniums. I had an equally good experience with nickel Titans on an 0-320. Superior had an engine option that suited me so I bought a complete engine from them rather than Lycoming. I'm a fan of aftermarket cylinders.
 
Salty said:
Cost difference is roughly $800 cheaper for the millenniums (about $200 per cylinder).
Click to expand...

Make sure you're comparing apples to apples. The aftermarket cylinders do not contain the same components as the OEMs do. Last I checked the price delta per cylinder was much smaller than that, when you actually compared the same components.

Due to the lack of difference in cost, and there appear to be more ADs affecting aftermarket cylinders, I'm a fan of using Lycoming.
 
mondtster said:
Make sure you're comparing apples to apples. The aftermarket cylinders do not contain the same components as the OEMs do. Last I checked the price delta per cylinder was much smaller than that, when you actually compared the same components.

Due to the lack of difference in cost, and there appear to be more ADs affecting aftermarket cylinders, I'm a fan of using Lycoming.
Click to expand...
That's true. I believe the Millenium's don't come with rocker arms or piston pin. I'm not certain if the Lycomings do or not.
 
I don't think any of them come with rocker arms.
 
Salty said:
That's true. I believe the Millenium's don't come with rocker arms or piston pin. I'm not certain if the Lycomings do or not.
Click to expand...

The Milleniums come with a rocker shaft, but no piston pin or plugs. The Lycomings come with piston pin, plugs, but no rocker shaft. That's what I recall from about a year ago, from the last engine I overhauled.

I want to say that the price difference between cylinder kits once all the parts were collected was $50ish per cylinder. That amounts to nearly nothing in the final cost of overhauling the engine.
 
I know the ECi Titans I got for my O-320 came with ringed piston with pin, valves with springs and the rocker shaft and gaskets. I didn't get rocker arms and didn't expect to. I was quite pleased with the cylinders and had no issues. I looked at the factory cylinders but they didn't have a nickel option and were about $200 more per jug. They didn't come with any more parts than the ECi jugs did.

Frank
 
BiffJ said:
I know the ECi Titans I got for my O-320 came with ringed piston with pin, valves with springs and the rocker shaft and gaskets. I didn't get rocker arms and didn't expect to. I was quite pleased with the cylinders and had no issues. I looked at the factory cylinders but they didn't have a nickel option and were about $200 more per jug. They didn't come with any more parts than the ECi jugs did.

Frank
Click to expand...
somehow "other" got dropped from the original poll. I added it now
 
Stewartb said:
I've had good service from my Cessna's Millenniums. I had an equally good experience with nickel Titans on an 0-320. Superior had an engine option that suited me so I bought a complete engine from them rather than Lycoming. I'm a fan of aftermarket cylinders.
Click to expand...

Millenniums are made by Superior, and are the only after market cylinders now available, ECI is no longer in business, Chinese bought them out and shut them down because they also own Lycoming and TCM.
Noe there is no after market cylinder that has a exhaust valve rotator.
and all cylinders have nearly doubled in price in the last 5 years.
no cylinders come with rocker arms.
 
Salty said:
somehow "other" got dropped from the original poll. I added it now
Click to expand...
Why add it? the only other option is rebuilt, the options you have are TCM, Lycoming, and Superior
 
ECI was purchased by Continental and subsequently all Continental cylinder production moved to San Antonio. They still produce PMAd replacement cylinders for Lycomings in through-hardened steel and nickel bores. They also still produce experimental Titan engines.
 
Tom-D said:
Millenniums are made by Superior, and are the only after market cylinders now available, ECI is no longer in business, Chinese bought them out and shut them down because they also own Lycoming and TCM.
Noe there is no after market cylinder that has a exhaust valve rotator.
and all cylinders have nearly doubled in price in the last 5 years.
no cylinders come with rocker arms.
Click to expand...
Because, unlike you ;), I don't know what I don't know.
 
Tom-D said:
Millenniums are made by Superior, and are the only after market cylinders now available, ECI is no longer in business, Chinese bought them out and shut them down because they also own Lycoming and TCM.
...
Click to expand...

The Chinese do NOT own Lycoming Tom.
 
Tom-D said:
So. your saying TCM cylinders are ECI's, if so, that's good news.

But that is not what my supplier says
http://www.aircraft-specialties.com/titan-cylinder-complete-assy-steel-tist61-1dca/
Click to expand...

Here is where you can get the CMI version of the Titans. My understanding is that CMI bought ECI out for their PMA Lycoming parts not to get them off the market but so they could offer the products themselves.

http://aeroinstock.com/air-boss-cylinder-assemblies-lycoming-engines/
 
Continental ditched their nitrided barrels and use ECI's through-hardened barrels. That's a good thing for Continental owners. No more convincing yourselves that 50/80 compressions are good. ;)

Superior uses through-hardened barrels, too, by the way.
 
GRG55 said:
The Chinese do NOT own Lycoming Tom.
Click to expand...

You are correct. That is at least the second time that I have seen that falsehood on POA. Not sure why it persists. I'm even thinking it might have been posted by the same person the last time. Lycoming is owned by AVCO who is owned by Textron. Last I checked, Textron was still American.

Edit: Here is the last time he posted that BS. See post 12.
 
Last edited:
mondtster said:
Due to the lack of difference in cost, and there appear to be more ADs affecting aftermarket cylinders, I'm a fan of using Lycoming.
Click to expand...
When my engine was overhauled I went with new Lycoming cylinder kits for this very reason. My mechanic said there were no ADs on the Lycoming cylinders. I have 200 hours on my new engine and I have been happy with my choice.
 
Tom-D said:
Do you see anything about 0-200/0-300 cylinders in those three links?
Click to expand...

Open the third link (Aviall) and turn the page by tapping the arrow on the right. 0-300 cylinders are in there.
 
SkyDog58 said:
You are correct. That is at least the second time that I have seen that falsehood on POA. Not sure why it persists. I'm even thinking it might have been posted by the same person the last time. Lycoming is owned by AVCO who is owned by Textron. Last I checked, Textron was still American.

Edit: Here is the last time he posted that BS. See post 12.
Click to expand...

Yes. Textron, which also owns Cessna, Beech and Bell Helicopters is a NYSE listed company.

I'm sure there's nothing to prevent someone from China from buying some stock, but its not a Chinese owned company for sure.
 
On a Lycoming I'd buy OEM Lycoming. I've never seen a factory new Lycoming cylinder not make it to TBO trouble-free. Can't say the same at all about aftermarket cylinders.

China does NOT own Lycoming.
 
Ted DuPuis said:
On a Lycoming I'd buy OEM Lycoming. I've never seen a factory new Lycoming cylinder not make it to TBO trouble-free. Can't say the same at all about aftermarket cylinders.

China does NOT own Lycoming.
Click to expand...
Ya but....you and I don't fly Lycoming engines. o_O
 
Continental San Antonio (was ECI/Titan) was closed a year or so ago. That manufacturing is now done at Continental's plant in Mobile. I toured the SA plant a couple of years ago.

Based on what I hear at the aviation "water cooler", I would shy away from the ECI/Titan/PMA'd Lyclone parts from Continental.
 
Tom-D said:
Millenniums are made by Superior, and are the only after market cylinders now available, ECI is no longer in business, Chinese bought them out and shut them down because they also own Lycoming and TCM.
Noe there is no after market cylinder that has a exhaust valve rotator.
and all cylinders have nearly doubled in price in the last 5 years.
no cylinders come with rocker arms.
Click to expand...
How do the Chinese own Lycoming? Lycoming is owned by Textron, HQ in Rhode Island.
Also, TCM hasn't been TCM in almost a decade now- it's been just CM. The T part is still a USA company.
 
Anyone have any bad experience with millennium cylinders? I'm torn between then and lycomings
 
Paulie said:
Anyone have any bad experience with millennium cylinders? I'm torn between then and lycomings
Click to expand...

Somebody will. Others won't. FYI, Barrett Precision Engines (a reputable shop) won't use ECI unless customer requested, but sees Superior and Lycoming cylinders as equally good.
 
Last edited:
All of our engines have been OH’d with Millenium’s with positive experiences for the most part. Millennium’s are arguably better than Lycoming, but with cylinder prices getting more competitive, AM brands are just marginally cheaper than Lycoming. They all have the same combustion chamber, exhaust and intake ports, etc. Personally, I don’t think you can go wrong with either, but if it were my own aircraft and I was calling the shots, I’d choose Lycoming over AM products.
 
Are cylinders not repairable/overhaul able? Based on what I have read about continental cylinders new from the factory, it seems like there should be better options.
 
Getonit said:
Are cylinders not repairable/overhaul able? Based on what I have read about continental cylinders new from the factory, it seems like there should be better options.
Click to expand...

Oftentimes repair costs exceed the cost to buy new cylinder kits, and sometimes don't last as long as new kits. That doesn't seem like a particularly desirable spot to be in to me, but some people still elect to go down that path.

With some engines repairing cylinders is your only option. Obviously you have to do what you have to, in order to make the engine useable again.
 
Getonit said:
Are cylinders not repairable/overhaul able? Based on what I have read about continental cylinders new from the factory, it seems like there should be better options.
Click to expand...
They are depending on their condition. Sometimes it makes sense to repair the existing cylinder and other times it’s just best to get new, but the cylinder barrel can be remachined to restore it back to factory limits. Depends on the situation.
 
Getonit said:
Are cylinders not repairable/overhaul able? Based on what I have read about continental cylinders new from the factory, it seems like there should be better options.
Click to expand...

The issue is that overhauling a cylinder costs almost as much as a brand new one. So cylinder repairs are waay down from years ago when the OEM's charged outrageous prices for new cylinders.
 
kyleb said:
The issue is that overhauling a cylinder costs almost as much as a brand new one. So cylinder repairs are waay down from years ago when the OEM's charged outrageous prices for new cylinders.
Click to expand...
If you can do them supervised it isn't that bad.....and you can get a stud exchange with new Nickel for $600. That's a far cry from new costs....if you already have serviceable valves and piston and all the other items.

New is much easier if you're the installer.
 
Checkout_my_Six said:
If you can do them supervised it isn't that bad.....and you can get a stud exchange with new Nickel for $600. That's a far cry from new costs....if you already have serviceable valves and piston and all the other items.

New is much easier if you're the installer.
Click to expand...

If you're willing to install a used exhaust valve, piston, etc., used is cheaper. I was thinking in terms of a cylinder rebuild which included a new valve, rings, piston, etc.
 
kyleb said:
If you're willing to install a used exhaust valve, piston, etc., used is cheaper. I was thinking in terms of a cylinder rebuild which included a new valve, rings, piston, etc.
Click to expand...
I exchanged 3 cylinders with Gibson and was impressed with what came back. New Nickel walls, new guides, and new seats and studs....and freshly painted. Not bad for the price.

You barely can get studs and exhaust port work for that.
 

Attachments

  • 00B89480-155E-426D-98C7-37B0BD7DC06B.jpg
    00B89480-155E-426D-98C7-37B0BD7DC06B.jpg
    181.3 KB · Views: 19
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top