Costco batteries.

wsuffa

Touchdown! Greaser!
Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Messages
23,615
Location
DC Suburbs
Display Name

Display name:
Bill S.
Three pieces of electronics equipment in which Costco batteries were installed. 3 more pieces of equipment that I have to clean out corrosion and battery leakage. 2 sets of batteries dated through 2021, on through 2022.

Seriously not happy. And seriously not impressed.
 
Costco house brand batteries ? Or other brands from Costco.
Don't have a Costco close here. 165 miles and across a mountain range to closest one in Montana ,
80 miles to closest in Canada.
 
I don't use anything other than Alkaline batteries because I hope they are more resistant to leaking. Although I don't use that many I haven't had one leak in years and years if ever.
 
When I think of all the devices I've had which were damaged by leaking batteries vs the ease with which class action lawsuits are filed in this country I am gobsmacked....
 
Generally Costco batteries were (past tense) OK with me, but I changed over to NiMH rechargeables and haven't looked back. I use so many AA batteries that buying them would be costly. The rechargeable batteries are convenient and have not leaked on me.
 
I don't use anything other than Alkaline batteries because I hope they are more resistant to leaking. Although I don't use that many I haven't had one leak in years and years if ever.
Actually, alkaline as a type are probably the most or second most prone to leaking. You’re better off with Energizer Lithium or LSD NiMH such as Eneloop. But if you must use alkaline for whatever reason, Energizer alkaline is probably the brand least likely to leak (although I’ve heard they still leak from time to time)
 
Duracell makes the Costco brand “Kirkland” batteries
 
I’ve had issues with Duracell brand in the past few years. They always leak when lose their charge. Switched to Energizer - let’s see if it helps.

Never had a single issue before maybe 2016, and almost all Duracell AA and AAA batteries I bought after that leaked at some point. I usually buy at Costco too.
 
what technology would be required to contain these meltdown? A reactor vessel?
Really, what would it take.
And, how high would battery prices go?
I'd pay 3x what I currently pay.
 
That would make sense, every time I open a device and find a leaking battery it's a Duracell.

Duracell had a major problem sometime back. I switched to amazon basics batteries, works well
 
I haven't caught any of my eneloops leaking yet. No reactor vessel necessary.
 
Yeah, they're Costco brand by Duracell. For the applications, it doesn't make sense to use the more expensive batteries, so I'm going to try the Amazon Basics (made by Fujitsu) next. We'll see.

Just annoying to have to clean up the devices, yet again, because of leakage.
 
There are two brands: real Duracels (packaged for Costco) and Kirkland (Costco's house label) also made by Duracel. I think the latter is only available in AA size. I've had leakages from both. I try not to leave alkaline batteries in things.
 
I used Kirkland batteries for years with no issues. Recently a lot of my Kirkland batteries have leaked and I won't be purchasing again. I moved to Amazon as well and so far no issues, but it's only been a year or so...
 
I don't think I have noticed Kirkland batteries leaking, but I've seen (and cleaned up after) numerous leaking Duracells.
 
Alkaline batteries will always leak at some point after they're discharged. The charge holds back the corrosion process that eventually leads to leaking. Once that protection ends, it's just a matter of time. It could be contained, and is for more toxic or more expensive batteries, but with disposable primary batteries there is no market for a pricey, short-lived battery. (That would be the other trade-off: space used for containment isn't available for creating charge.)

The exterior steel can is part of the electrical circuit of the battery. You'll see that you connect directly to it on both sides. Most leaks come from rust forming on the bottom junction around the plastic separator that keeps the positive end insulated from the negative end. Once enough rust forms to break the seal, it's going to leak out. (Also helps that a dead battery produces some gas as it breaks down, increasing internal pressure.)

I haven't noticed that Costco batteries leak at any higher rate than anyone else. Interesting to know they're made by Duracel. It's certainly possible that Energizer has a more resistant seal at the bottom.
 
Back
Top