To DME or not to DME

luvflyin

Touchdown! Greaser!
Joined
May 8, 2015
Messages
16,169
Location
Santa Barbara, CA
Display Name

Display name:
Luvflyin
Some fixes are both Intersections and DME fixes. Logic dictates if you have DME, use that instead of doing the cross radial boogie to define the fix. But is there something that mandates you use DME if you file with a DME suffix code. FAR, AIM, AC, etc.
 
I'm assuming you don't have a GPS. I've not turned on my DME in the 16 years I've had an IFR WAAS GPS. I only kept the thing because it was practically brand new when I put the new panel in and I wasn't hurting for the space.
There's only two approaches that one would argue that you can't substitute GPS for and the FAA says that you can anyway (I don't agree with their reasoning, but I'm not going to argue).

I agree with Maule's analysis.
 
I've a DME. I have to admit, if it broke I'd try and buy a working one off Ebay. It can give you some extra situational awareness. And another toy to play with on a long flight.
 
Until the GPS signal goes kaput! ;)
That's going to be a rather serious event, and the loss of DME isn't a disaster. I'll still have VOR and LOC nav.

I put the DME in te plane before IFR GPS was a thing. The most convenient approach to my home airport required DME and it was so darn convenient flying around the DC class B (back when you could do that at your leisure). Even the latter was largely surplanted when I got my first handheld GPS (serial #9 of the Garmin 195).
 
For a plane that already has both a navigator and a DME I wouldn’t be in a hurry to yank out the DME unless I was desperate for the panel real estate. Folks, there are all sorts of events that can result in the loss of satellite signals other than Global Thermonuclear war. It happens. Having redundancy is a good thing.
 
Yeah, totally just a fad.
He means outages, scheduled or unscheduled. I've flown through two so far (one when I was IFR and one when I was VFR). GPS is very reliable, except when they jam it or turn it off, so it's helpful to have a backup, like with everything else in our planes.
 
Now that I don't fly for a living anymore, I really miss having DME. I also don't own my own plane, so I have no idea how much it would cost to have it installed, so I dunno if it would be worth it, especially with a lot of VOR approaches going away, but I sure did like using it.
 
I can't remember if I shared this here before, but years ago I was flying a Hope Air flight VFR direct from Ottawa to Timmons, which means about 2 hours of nothing but lakes and woods over the unpopulated area of far West Quebec before rejoining roads and towns for the last hour and a half.

About an hour in, once I was well out of sight of the Ottawa River to the south (the only major geographical feature in the area), my usually-trusty portable Garmin 696 suddenly froze up and wouldn't reboot. I had a moment of discomfort, then reminded myself that—while it would take a lot of time to identify any specific little lake under me from the thousands on the map—I had already been flying in the right direction, so if I just kept held that heading for another 30-45 minutes, I'd be close enough to pick up the Earlton NDB (now decommissioned) to refine my course, then it would be easy pilotage from that point on along the Trans-Canada Highway or radio nav following VOR and NDB airways. Other options would have included following a VOR radial southwest to North Bay, adding a fuel stop, then continuing to Timmins from there, but I didn't want to inconvenience my (medical patient) passenger and their escort that much, especially since they were already nervous flying in a light piston single. I was also stuck at 3,000 ft below a cloud deck, so VOR reception wasn't going to be easy with the far-spread-out VORs around there (NDB was a better bet, because LF/MF signals hug the earth and have lower reception altitudes compared to the line-of-sight VHF VORs).

In the event, it took a while (I didn't have an autopilot back then, so had to do everything in 5 second segments while hand flying the plane), but I finally got the back off the 696 and pulled the battery, which forced it to shut down, then put it back together and it booted up normally.

This was not an emergency or even a particularly stressful time—I was VFR, I had lots of fuel, and a good, workable plan B and C etc…—but it did teach me always to be able to put my finger down on a paper chart and show where I am, no matter what other tech I have on board. These days, I have a panel-mounted GPS, aviation apps on a phone and tablet, and an autopilot, but I also believe that only a sucker (like I was) would ever assume that when you have a GPS you don't need anything else.

I've also flown through two GPS outages since then (one scheduled and one unscheduled), but they didn't cause any distress, because I always have backup plans.
 
In the event, it took a while (I didn't have an autopilot back then, so had to do everything in 5 second segments while hand flying the plane), but I finally got the back off the 696 and pulled the battery, which forced it to shut down, then put it back together and it booted up normally.
Thereby releasing a crazy bit or two.
 
Back
Top