We had a healthy discussion on the Mooney Pilots group on Facebook regarding landing technique that morphed a bit into short field landings, and there were plenty of unresolved assertions. Well, my engineer brain didn't like that, and my pilot brain decided that doing some testing sounded like fun.
I’m planning to do some research/flight testing to determine the theoretical and actual effectiveness of some different techniques, and I figured that crowdsourcing the design of the tests would help to make them as effective as possible. I will take another pilot with me to help collect and record the data safely. I’ll update the remainder of this post as we refine the plan:
First of all, to eliminate as many variables as possible, I’ll do all my approaches to the same runway, using the GTN 750 visual approach feature with autopilot and a consistent power setting so that the approaches are all the same. That means at least a 3-mile final, I’ll probably plan a base leg around 4 miles out and drop the gear at 3 miles as the glide slope is intercepted.
I’ll also rotate through the following scenarios rather than doing all reps of a single scenario and moving on to the next scenario. By rotating through them, the effect of the inevitable changes in wind, temperature, and aircraft weight should be minimized.
I’ll have a GoPro mounted underneath the plane to help with measuring where touchdown and the end of the roll occur.
I'm planning on doing the entire following list of scenarios 3 times. Here are the scenarios I’m thinking of doing:
1) Flap retraction time, engine off.
2) Flap retraction time, engine running, airplane stationary on the ground.
3) Flap retraction time, in slow flight.
(The above don’t need to be in the rotation, as they don’t involve a landing - I'll do them first)
4) Landing distance and flap retraction time during landing roll, no wheel braking. Will take airspeed at touchdown, beginning and end of retraction as well as the amount of time it takes for retraction.
(All of the above will give us the time it takes to retract flaps and determine the variation, if any, caused by differing bus voltages and aerodynamic loads.)
5) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout landing roll, no wheel braking.
6) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout Landing, speed brakes extended upon touchdown, no wheel braking.
7) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout landing, speed brakes extended at end of flare, no wheel braking
8.) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout landing, speed brakes extended at beginning of flare, no wheel braking.
9) Landing distance, flaps down throughout landing, speed brakes extended at end of flare, nose held off until control effectiveness is lost, then full aft elevator for remainder of landing roll, no wheel braking.
(“Max braking effort” as used below means as much pressure as possible without skidding, thus the pressure will necessarily vary throughout each individual landing roll and between tests.)
4a) Landing distance, Flaps retracted upon touchdown, max effort braking after retraction complete, elevator neutral
4b) Landing distance, flaps retracted upon touchdown, max effort braking right away, elevator neutral
5a) Landing distance, flaps down throughout landing roll, max effort braking
6a) Landing distance, flaps down throughout landing roll, speed brakes extended upon touchdown, max effort braking
7a) Landing distance, flaps down throughout landing roll, speed brakes extended at end of flare, max effort braking
8a) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout landing, speed brakes extended at beginning of flare, max effort braking.
10) Landing distance, Flaps down throughout landing, speed brakes extended at end of flare, elevator full aft, max effort braking.
I’ll do the tests in the following order to minimize the effects of brake temperature: 4a, 4,4b, 5, 5a, 6, 6a, 7, 7a, 8, 8a, 9, 10. I’ll also take a break after each series to help with my alertness and performance, replace the batteries in the GoPro, and give the brakes a chance to cool further.
Other data to record: Temp, Dewpoint, and winds for each test.
Any thoughts or suggestions are appreciated. I've got a
thread on the Mooney Pilots group, but I'm posting the link here mainly because it's freaking impossible to find anything on Facebook after a couple of days have passed.