Radar App for near by airplanes to maximize saftey?

A

aeronav

Pre-Flight
Joined
Jul 26, 2018
Messages
44
Display Name
Display name:
AeroNav
Hello,
I am PP student, I have been looking for an app that have the ability to show near by aircraft position to use as a secondary precaution to VFR to maximize safety, I have only few hours flying and so far i feel that I have no special issues with aircraft control, the only thing that worries me and bothers me are other aircraft specially near the school airport that may pass by, in my few flying hours with the instructor i have seen aircraft that were not too close to us but they were close enough to raised my alarm, on one of my flying lessons I turned almost 60% of my focus and attention away from the lesson and instead was scanning the sky for potential near by aircraft because I was worried, I don't always hear the tower advising us on the radio about near by aircraft when I see them. I might be excessively cautious about this because I am new but seeing some reports and news like this one https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/mid-air-collision-reported-at-t31.100290/ makes me worried.
Naturally trainer aircraft do not have radars on board, so i was looking for alternative just to maximize safety.
Thank you.
 
Foreflight paired with ADSB is the best you’ll do in that department. There are no stand alone apps that display VFR traffic in such a way other than FF/GP.
 
ADSB in gizmo broadcasting on your iThing
 
Don't worry. Be happy. The sky is big and our planes are small.

Keep looking outside, too. . .the tech is just good enough to kill you.
 
Your outside scan is what you need. Your distraction outside is fine. Once you keep your head in the cockpit looking at a device for traffic is when you’re gonna be in trouble. Head down and eyes inside is a bad habit. Just my opinion. ADSB traffic is extremely distracting and I have not grown to like it yet.

But yes, as the guys above responded. Smart phone or tablet, an EFB app (from free to upward in cost), and ADSB-in hardware (from low cost Stratux on up).
 
All you need for PPL training is to look outside. Absolutely everything that causes you to move your focus inside the cockpit is potentially deadly,

Play video games on the ground or when someone else is flying.
 
Thanks for all your valuable inputs.
 
Put down the damn phone and look at the world around you.
 
aeronav said:
Thanks for all your valuable inputs.
Click to expand...

Just keep in mind, no matter what gizmo you use, it will not capture all traffic around you, unless you have TCAS system in your aircraft. As others have mentioned, keep your eyes out
 
Electronic methods are always a supplement -- and secondary -- to good visual lookout.

I used to fly a jet with a very powerful air interdiction radar, and my primary method of detecting and avoiding traffic was my eyeballs.

"Check twelve".
 
I agree on what others have said, part of your training is multitasking to a certain degree. Always looking for traffic while maneuvering, on cross country's, and in and around the pattern.
The purpose of on board radar is only for weather avoidance.
You can't "see" all the traffic on an app or device anyways, some of us are flying around without transponders when we're away from the metro areas.
 
WannFly said:
Just keep in mind, no matter what gizmo you use, it will not capture all traffic around you, even if you have TCAS system in your aircraft.
Click to expand...
FTFY.
TCAS / ADS-B do not pick up no-transponder aircraft: Gliders, no-electric aircraft (Cubs, Flybaby's, etc.), part 103, etc.
 
Hacker said:
Electronic methods are always a supplement -- and secondary -- to good visual lookout.
....
"Check twelve".
Click to expand...

I’m reminded of the MACA brief at Red Flag and the accompanying video.
 
aeronav said:
Hello,
I am PP student, I have been looking for an app that have the ability to show near by aircraft position to use as a secondary precaution to VFR to maximize safety, I have only few hours flying and so far i feel that I have no special issues with aircraft control, the only thing that worries me and bothers me are other aircraft specially near the school airport that may pass by, in my few flying hours with the instructor i have seen aircraft that were not too close to us but they were close enough to raised my alarm, on one of my flying lessons I turned almost 60% of my focus and attention away from the lesson and instead was scanning the sky for potential near by aircraft because I was worried, I don't always hear the tower advising us on the radio about near by aircraft when I see them. I might be excessively cautious about this because I am new but seeing some reports and news like this one https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/mid-air-collision-reported-at-t31.100290/ makes me worried.
Naturally trainer aircraft do not have radars on board, so i was looking for alternative just to maximize safety.
Thank you.
Click to expand...

The plane we fly has ADSB in the 430W GPS. When flying local, I use it in the "fish finder" mode that shows the surrounding traffic. However, I use that as a backup to visually scanning for traffic. Usually I scan for traffic, if I don't find any planes, I glance at the 430 just to confirm. If I find something there, I look outside for the target.
Remember that there are planes flying without transponder mode C or ADBS-out so they'll not show in the system.
 
aeronav said:
Hello,
I am PP student, I have been looking for an app that have the ability to show near by aircraft position to use as a secondary precaution to VFR to maximize safety, I have only few hours flying and so far i feel that I have no special issues with aircraft control, the only thing that worries me and bothers me are other aircraft specially near the school airport that may pass by, in my few flying hours with the instructor i have seen aircraft that were not too close to us but they were close enough to raised my alarm, on one of my flying lessons I turned almost 60% of my focus and attention away from the lesson and instead was scanning the sky for potential near by aircraft because I was worried, I don't always hear the tower advising us on the radio about near by aircraft when I see them. I might be excessively cautious about this because I am new but seeing some reports and news like this one https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/mid-air-collision-reported-at-t31.100290/ makes me worried.
Naturally trainer aircraft do not have radars on board, so i was looking for alternative just to maximize safety.
Thank you.
Click to expand...

Your eyeballs will works just fine. Hard as it might be for you to understand, we have been flying near other airplanes since before the word "app" became a thing. Yes, before radar and transponders...and at airports without towers, too! Electronic gadgetry has in many ways diminished aviation safety rather than enhanced it.

"almost 60%" of your focus is not nearly enough....you should be scanning constantly. Gently ask your instructor to back off on the rapid-fire instructions to give you time for scanning,

Bob
 
Can’t believe what I’m reading. POA recommending eye balls over gizmos??? Where are my usual tech geeks when you need them. :D

Well, not being one that’s big on whizz- bangitry myself, I will say that I enjoy TCAD and it’s not even close to being a distraction. But, it is in the panel (no head down) and has audio alerts so that helps minimize time inside. Like Hacker said, it’s by no means 100 % accurate.
 
ADS-B, at least initially, is a distraction. When you first turn it on you'll see a screen full of traffic but your mind is not quick enough to determine that none of the targets are of any consequence to you because they are not on an intercepting course. I imagine someday there will be an app that filters it all out and will only display relevant traffic but for now you have to learn how to dismiss most of what you see and do it quickly without staring at the screen trying to figure it all out. As a student you already have enough on your plate and spotting traffic visually is one of the skills that you need to develop so work on that first.
 
ADSB and nexrad weather radar and all are good, but they do inherently have some decent sized flaws, like the others said, enjoy the tech but don’t rely on it.

Also the chance of you getting in a mid air is quite small, you’d do better to do some offfield landing work with a good backcountry CFI and also be well versed in slips, both are much more likely to save your bacon
 
On the way to the airport you drove six feet away from hundreds of strangers going the opposite direction without any fear. You probably negotiated intersections and merged with other strangers.
The only thing keeping you from a nasty wreck was a basic understanding of the rules.

What radar did you use?
 
Hacker said:
I'm sure a post-millenial will be along any moment with an app for that, too.
Click to expand...

Actually the last econobox I rented had some radar tied into the cruise control
 
Young Eagle rallye this past weekend. When everything was over, I took one of my CS students (he's got a part-time gig at Jeppesen and had never been in a small airplane) for a short flight. By this time, I had packed up the GPS, the iPad, the ADSB, so all I had was the Mark 1 Eyeball, the compass and a paper of our local area we give to new YE pilots.

Had a wonderful 30 minutes, and no, I don't need all the tech all the time. Was worried about was busting Bravo, because FTG sits below DEN. But I kept below 7000, know the local landmarks and life was fine.
 
VFR, eyeballs outside 75% of the time. Read it somewhere, sounds about right. The state of the art in radar, GPS, gizmos is still pretty crude. Mid-airs in cruise flight are very rare - weather or loss of control or fuel exhaustion is more likely to kill you.
 
jordane93 said:
MK1 Eyeball. Lots of good reviews on the App Store. Check it out.
Click to expand...

The internet also has plenty of opinions about how obsolete the eyeball is. I'm actually happily surprised to see people advocating for it here, because on the airline-centric forums it is usually a chorus singing, "GA AIRPLANES SHOULD ALL HAVE TCAS! VISUAL LOOKOUT IS A RELIC OF THE PAST AND DANGEROUS!!"
 
Hacker said:
The internet also has plenty of opinions about how obsolete the eyeball is. I'm actually happily surprised to see people advocating for it here, because on the airline-centric forums it is usually a chorus singing, "GA AIRPLANES SHOULD ALL HAVE TCAS! VISUAL LOOKOUT IS A RELIC OF THE PAST AND DANGEROUS!!"
Click to expand...
I love TIS when I fly GA but sometimes it’s just easier and more effective to look outside the window. Same thing with the radar. If it’s clear, my eyeballs do a good job deviating around buildups. If I’m IMC or I want to take a closer look at things, I throw on the radar.
 
You seemed quick to discount/downplay the traffic called out by the tower. They have good information for you, they don't need ADSB and they don't even need to be talking to those planes to help you out. In time you will hear those calls...while flying.

If you are really early into lessons you can rely on your CFI but when you solo and especially solo XC you are going to want to catch all those calls.

Try a busy pancake breakfast at an uncontrolled airport or a Bravo transition with FF. You'll be glad by then that the basic flying is more or less second nature as your brain shifts towards hearing and then quickly visualizing each call out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top