Kind of an interesting situation. I wonder how different it’d be if he wasn’t in a cirrus. Know what I mean?
Not trying to start anything, but if he was in a Mooney, or a Piper, or a Bo, I wonder how the different factions would act.
There are some critical folks over at COPA, but it’s largely positive. Kinda not surprised it’s getting ripped up on beechtalk.
I honestly don’t know how I feel about it. On the one hand, he’s trying his best to help. That’s admirable. On the other, it wasn’t asked for. But most pilots I know aren’t the type to ask for help in that situation. But he also wasn’t asked to STFU by the Piper.
Forgetting his rates, doing some research on COPA, he’s pretty highly regarded. Sure, I think some have issues with how he does what he does (the edge of the envelope stuff) but others see it as valuable. He’s got 1000 hours in that Piper, and as a full-time instructor he likely knows what he’s talking about. But again, it wasn’t asked for. But sounds like it was appreciated.
The forming up doesn’t bother me. He’s the Maverick to the Piper’s Cougar.
I’ve done formation flying clinics. He didn’t do anything unsafe while forming up. And everyone was aware of it. Even though it wasn’t asked for. But it wasn’t unsafe. I’ve been closer than he was as a wingman.
Was it a real emergency? Not sure. Doesn’t seem like it. The Piper pilot seemed pretty calm. I just don’t know.
Closest issue I had was when my power gauges went to hell flying back from Portland. Went from 75% to 16%. Then zero. Engine running fine. Diverted to Davis because there’s a great cirrus shop. ATC asked why I was diverting and they asked if I wanted to declare. I said no. Everything was running fine (at the time) but I was damn nervous something was going to go to hell. Anyway, it was just a connection issue. Fixed and flew out same day.
I bring that up because, while it wasn’t an emergency..... would I have appreciated Alex intercepting and forming up and taking to me? Probably not. But maybe. I had it under control. But what if I didn’t but thought I did?
One can arm chair this from either “side” ... I just don’t think I have a side.