I always got a kick out of the Bridge of a Starship always being on the upper deck of a warship and not buried well within the structure.
The new Battlestar Galactica at least gave a nod to this Engineering reality. They also had to drag their provisions around with them, dealt with scarcity of resources and rioting for part of a season, etc.
They were a little too hung up on the "racial tension" thing in the new one. "Cylons are People Too!". The ending was totally stupid.
Baltar's character as Christ-like religious leader in the new one was interesting. Colonel Tighe's charter acted a hell of a lot more like a real human stuck in the XO seat for way too many years, by his own choices.
And that thing with his wife in a concentration camp setting? Wild for a SciFi show. Very dark.
A crusty old Adama was okay, but the love story between him and the President... Meh. Liked his acting, but they didn't write his character all that well.
BSG's "nukes in space" was a hell of a lot better than the Federation running around with their hippie-dippy lasers that never seem to even put a scratch in anything larger than a shuttlecraft.
Your *flagship* has some wimpy lasers and a couple of photon torpedoes that never seem to be available when needed??
Voyager barely gave a nod to a possible full mutiny during a voyage that long and boring. People'd have eaten Janeway and her crew alive and gone for a stellar Party Cruise fueled by synthohol and cheetos from the food synthesizers, eventually.
And Ten Forward with Gynan/Whoopie Goldberg on TNG?! Yeah. Right. The Federation outfitted their flagship with a huge party bar forward and hired the wise old politically correct Rastafarian to tend bar. Sure. Haha. Sounds like the future military fleet. Haha.
Watching the Federation get it's wimpy little butt kicked for a couple of seasons of Deep Space Nine was satisfying though. Captain Sisko had a great voice, though. Harkened back to Shatner in that the Captain's voice was "unique". Come to think of it, Picard and Janeway also had distinctive voices.
The Federation had their butt-kicking coming on DS9 when a whole frakkin' (ha!) rescue armada showed up without so much as a new secret weapon to fight back with?!
We're going to the battle of our lives with... Phasers again!!
Sticking a remote base at the wormhole without so much as a medium cruiser close by is pretty stupid too.
Didn't these people ever play the board game, Risk?
And of course the only bad guys powerful enough to break up the hippie party in the first place were slaves to their passive-aggressive masters because they were addicted to a liquid drug? Yeah, because you know... The drug necessary for conquering a quadrant wouldn't have been easier to manage in pill form.
The sneaky Cardassians were kinda fun on that show, though. Ruthless.
Ferengi? Let 'em build up a business and take it from them by force. They were fun but would've been wiped out.
The Dax character was fun. Ancient being with nine-lives so to speak, chillin' in different host bodies 60-80 years at a time. Okay, kinda cool.
Borg. Very cool.
The "Q" character? Annoying. A being that powerful dorking around with Enterprise constantly? Writer's block I guess.
To seek out New Civilizations and have our flagship's ass kicked by every one of them... unless mega-genius child Wesley Crusher is aboard. He'll come up with something. Hahaha.
The only shocker in TNG was that Tasha Yar was another typical large-breasted not-self-conscious-in-skin-tight-uniforms female of the Future... that they actually killed off.
I always wondered what she did or said to Jonathan Frakes to get canned.
They also never showed the schoolkids laughing nervously every time they heard an adult called, "Number One" or even a few Ensigns making fun of the same.
"Yeah, he's Number One all right!"
BSG's Cylon in Baltar's head was waaaaaay hotter than anything Star Trek ever dreamed of.
![Wink ;) ;)](https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/joypixels/assets/8.0/png/unicode/64/1f609.png)
Whew. Hot.
All BSG was really missing was the cool Cylon voice from the original... "By Your Command..." Why'd they write that out?! That voice was wicked back in the day.
Having a stark-raving lunatic female Admiral show up with another Battlestar mid-way through the seasons was brilliant. Gotta love a good showdown with sidearms drawn between Officers in the CIC.
A little torture down in the Brig. A bunch of politicians royally screwing over their people while meaning well. A little reincarnation complete with full memory thrown in.
Yeah, the new BSG was quite entertaining. Waaay better than anything after Kirk's Trek. All were fun but BSG kicked it up a notch.