Thank you, that's exactly where I'm at -- between over thinking it and worried I might be overlooking some critical info. You came in from the Northwest when you were there?
Have come at it from several directions, landed both directions to.
Lots of room to fly downwind, base, and final. Maybe it's because I learned to fly in British Columbia Canada, but I found it extremely simple. If you ever find yourself in BC, come to Mabel lake, land, and have a visit. I'll take you out flying, and show you some interesting places to land. You have a Cherokee six correct? They are actually a good plane for reasonable small strips, even grass or gravel. I do find that a common mistake made by people who usually fly into and out of lower airports, is they try to take off at full rich mixture, or barely leaned out. I lean out slightly in taxi, then do my run up and after mag checks, I lean it to max power, taxi into position and then take off. People who don't live in the mountains are scared to lean, or forget to. The engine is running so pig rich at even just 4,000 feet asl, imagine how much it is over fueled at 9,000.
And again it's cool up at Telluride, in mid summer, in mid afternoon you might get up to 75F. Any other season, morning, evening, it is more likely going to be 5F - 50F. You might find your density altitude is only 6,000 - 7,000 feet. In the Okanagan region where I live we can be at over 100F, 2,000 feet of grass, and 4,000 feet asl, but density altitude of 7,000. Those are the days that make your butt pucker. 7,100 feet of asphalt is like a pilot's dream airport for people like me. My home strip is 2,900 feet of grass, but in summer temps soar, and it still feel long to me. My last flight was to an airport with 5,500 feet of asphalt, and a parallel 1,600 feet grass strip. I purposely chose the grass runway. That particular airport has a tricky situation to it though, you can either come in over a steep hill right at the end of the airport, or be faced with it if you have to do a missed approach.
My home grass strip is either land uphill towards tall trees, or land downhill after coming in over the trees. But at 2,900 feet long the options are open. The mountains are not tight to the runways ends in Telluride either, you are flying off into open air with plenty of room for lazy turns once up. Biggest thing is to just remain calm always, panic is what kills pilots too frequently. Panic leads to poor decisions, poor decisions are deadly.