Today my friend and I went riding on his BMWs:
First I rode the R1200GS, and then the G310GS. I liked both of them a great deal, more than I honestly thought I would.
The riding wasn’t necessarily traditional adventure bike territory, but we ended up riding from Brooklyn up to Sleepy Hollow NY where we then swapped bikes and rode back. For those unfamiliar, New York roads are filled with potholes, and are generally in poor quality. To that end, they end up being good for testing the suspensions over rough-ish terrain in the urban jungle. We also got some highway where we could get some faster speeds checked.
At my friend’s suggestion, I rode the R1200GS first. It’s a 2017 (I think, something around then) and has a great amount of technology in it. While it’s no secret that I’m more than a bit of a Luddite and normally prefer as few technological aids as possible, in this case I found them mostly helpful and things I liked. Unlike Kansas, we had lots of stop and go traffic , and loud it shifting, etc. Plus sitting on Gilles at stop lights/signs. Little features that normally annoy me like the hill start assist and the auto shift clutch (tap the shifter up or down while moving) I found to be rather nice to have to give my hands a break. The big bright screen didn’t have much lag in it so, while I tend to prefer analog gauges, this was nice.
I played around with some of the active modes that controlled the suspension, brakes, and engine. I see the benefit of it for some people, although for me that was less of an issue on this drive and I could’ve done without that and the extra buttons.
Suspension over the bumps and potholes was excellent. I was aiming for some pretty bait holes to see how it did, and it was still quite comfortable. Yet at speed it wasn’t soft or floaty. In fact, it was very confident at highway speed and the windshield didn’t produce any buffeting of my helmet and also blocked enough air that it was clear it could be a comfortable iron butt bike.
What impressed me the most was how lightweight the motorcycle felt to me. Despite being over 500 lbs and heavier than that cheap Benelli I rode last weekend, it felt much lighter weight. If I’d have guessed how much it weighed with my eyes closed and just on picking it up off the stand, I would’ve guessed closer to 425-450. Really a nice bike all around.
I then rode the G310GS. The bike costs maybe 1/5 what the big R1200GS costs, basically no features besides ABS, and something around 35 HP. With a small single cylinder it needed to rev high to make that power, but it was geared well and although it was obviously slower than the big one, it still felt fun and adequately powered below 60-65. At faster highway speeds, it definitely felt wound up and out of its element. The suspension on the highway would tend to wobble a bit if I gave it a bit of a step function input on the bats, but not awfully so. And similarly when hitting bad bumps you could tell it didn’t handle them quite as well as the bigger GS, but it was still comfortable and confident enough with them. My friends then drove me to the airport to catch my flight in their Mini, and I noted how much firmer the suspension was on the Mini than either bike.
Really, I liked both of them a lot, and it makes me excited to see how I like the R1150GS I’ll be riding in the next couple weeks. Being older and more agricultural, I suspect I’ll like it a bit more, but I also bet it won’t be as confident in the highway and feel heavier than that 1200GS.