Ted
The pilot formerly known as Twin Engine Ted
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2007
- Messages
- 30,006
- Display Name
Display name:
iFlyNothing
Boats should generally be purchased according to what you want to do with it, and where you will be using it.
I am not a pontoon fan, personally, in all but a few cases (usually involving frequent boating in really shallow water, or catfishing). If I wanted the open/flat-deck layout, I'd go for a deck boat. Similar layout to the pontoon, but worlds better in handling, fuel-efficiency, and ride comfort. The gunnels of most boats (bass boats not included) are more than sufficient to hold in small children, often times taller than the 24" rail on a pontoon/deck boat will.
With small kids (under age 5 or so), they usually aren't as interested in skiing/tubing as much, and certainly not at any speed above what a pontoon will do. One of the most important things is to have something with a large bimini top to keep them in the shade while they play. Cuddy cabins are okay, but can get stuffy if you boat in any place where it's 95+ degrees in summer. Most people end up using cuddy cabins in the south for storage more than anything else. We used to go play on the water for 2 hours or so, pull up to a beach and have a picnic lunch, then swim/Frisbee/football for an hour, then back on the boat for another 2 hours or so for a second round of watersports or just cruising around. Then call it a day and head-in. 6hrs on the water is generally plenty for most people, and the sun will really take it out of you if you don't have shade available.
We are lucky to have family with lake-front houses/docks on two local lakes, so we can go play for a few hours, then come back inside and rest/relax. It's easier to deal with small children who decide they no longer want to be on the water when you can offload them within 30 minutes and keep on boating with those who still want to be out.
Agree 100% with your opening sentence.
The cuddy cabin was a great boat for what we bought it for initially. When we started out, the cabin was a great place to throw the kids (they were smaller) for loading/unloading. Plus a good place to store stuff. Many naps happened in that cabin, and it worked well. So we still think this was the right boat to purchase when we did.
I'm not a pontoon fan myself and had dismissed them for that reason. However, the reasons make sense and I could get converted going back to buying a boat for the mission and for what we're doing. I also like your suggestion of a deck boat and we'll look into those as well. For what we're looking for now, no real reason why a pontoon won't work. I figure in a few years they'll be ready to ski and we'll be looking for something else again anyway.