The Media and the Gulf of Mexico

Jay Honeck

Touchdown! Greaser!
Joined
Jun 6, 2008
Messages
11,571
Location
Ingleside, TX
Display Name

Display name:
Jay Honeck
I own a motel on the Texas gulf coast, and would like to make a couple of observations about how the national media-types have been playing two recent events: the BP oil spill, and Hurricane Alex.

WRT to the oil spill, see this article, for reference: http://news.yahoo.com/s/csm/20100701/ts_csm/311973

Since the media first awakened to the magnitude of the spill, we have been battling the image that the entire Gulf of Mexico is awash in oil. The media continues to exacerbate this problem by playing on the fears of geographically-challenged Americans, many of whom couldn't find Louisiana on a map for a million bucks. Now, articles like this are claiming that people who swim in the gulf are getting sick!

I know most of you know this, but the Gulf of Mexico is an ENORMOUS body of water, and the oil is 500 miles away. Better yet, it's drifting AWAY from Texas. No one is getting sick here swimming in the gulf, unless they're trying to drink it. But that doesn't stop the headline writers from painting the entire gulf as some sort of disaster area.

Heck, even Doonesbury is constantly talking about the "flammable shrimp" from the gulf. It's insanely ignorant, and is causing people down here real harm -- because people read that strip and stop eating shrimp.

Now, Hurricane Alex.

It's funny -- at first I thought "My God, the weather people down here are just as bad as they were in Iowa" (where they are constantly warning people about "life-threatening wind-chills, and other such nonsense, as if people don't know it's cold outside?) -- but I quickly realized that they are THE SAME PEOPLE. CNN, FoxNews, The Weather Channel, they all make their money on advertising, and nothing sells like a good ol' "catastrophic event" -- whether it exists, or not. And the local TV stations all jump on the band-wagon, dollar signs in their eyes.

For days the forecasters were predicting that Alex -- barely a hurricane -- wasn't going to hit the United States. Nevertheless, endless stories showing people in Corpus Christi buying water and generators, and breathless Jim Cantori inexplicably standing outside in a driving rain storm managed to scare the bejeezus out of many geographically-challenged tourists. As a result, the Fourth of July weekend -- the biggest of the summer -- has been ruined up and down the Gulf coast -- even though Alex was nothing but a rain event, and the weather here is quite nice.

We've seen storms a thousand times worse in the Midwest, dozens of times -- heck, storms are a way of life in the tornado belt. (In fact, our other motel in Iowa has been HAMMERED by weather this summer.) We have even seen storms HERE that were far worse. With Alex we didn't hear a single crack of thunder -- not even a single bolt of lightning -- yet people were literally scared to come here. It's just goofy.

Again, I'm probably preaching to the choir here, and maybe this is a post-Katrina phenomenon, but people need to remember that when the media types are standing out in the wind and rain, telling everyone that they are going to DIE -- they are doing it for one reason, and one reason only: Advertising sales. Never let a good crisis go to waste -- real or not.

And, of course, there is real danger in over-hyping these sorts of things. Next time, when it may really BE a disaster, who will listen?

So, the sun is out, and it's VFR weather here today -- but the island is dead. Everyone made other plans, thanks to the over-hyped, over-blown media hoopla about two non-events.

The good news? Any of you folks who didn't make plans for the Fourth Weekend yet and want to enjoy a few days on Mustang Island, come on down! We've got plenty of rooms, and -- for a change -- you'll be able to easily get into all the bars and restaurants... :thumbsup:
 
Sorry to hear Jay. There are parts of the Gulf Coast that are affected by the disaster, but I am thankful that yours is not one of them.

We had the equivalent of a Cat I hurricane blow through here one year and it was amazing. I had never seen anything like that ever before, and I've had close calls with tornadoes. I am glad Alex turned out to be a non-event, but better safe than sorry. After what I saw, I decided it takes a special kind of stupid to tangle with a storm like that. I certainly won't.

I hope that despite this the business is doing what you want and you are enjoying Texas as much as you thought you would. Based on what little I know about you and what little I know about Texas, it seemed a good fit.
 
I agree that the media over-hypes things and that Americans are geographically challenged but if I was considering taking a weekend trip I wouldn't pick someplace where the forecast was bad. Hurricane or not, there would still be the large chance of unfavorable weather, even if it wasn't dangerous.
 
Jay,

Just remember the purpose of the Media is TO MAKE MONEY. The "chinese wall" between the news and entertainment functions came down a long time ago, and there's no ethical standard of conduct left anywhere (though some individuals do show signs now and then) in print, video, or radio, possibly with the exception of the Christian Science Monitor (which has it's own viewpoint, but at least it doesn't try to pass itself off as anything else).

If you do any advertising - you should do an ad that says "Learn what the media and the government AREN'T TELLING YOU. There's clear water and clean beaches in the Gulf of Mexico. There are sunny days and smiles all around. Just visit Mustang Island for your perfect vacation".
 
I agree that the media over-hypes things and that Americans are geographically challenged but if I was considering taking a weekend trip I wouldn't pick someplace where the forecast was bad. Hurricane or not, there would still be the large chance of unfavorable weather, even if it wasn't dangerous.

Oh, I understand that, and have no quarrel with it. No one would pick a weekend that is showing constant rain.

My point is the over-hyped, end-of-the-world coverage for two non-events.

I just got off the phone with the owner of five beach-wear stores on the island. She is trying to gauge what her business was going to be like, based on hotel business.

She told me she's probably not going to open all of them, and the ones that will be open are going to be on shortened hours.

Meanwhile, the sun is shining... :confused:
 
Jay,

Just remember the purpose of the Media is TO MAKE MONEY. The "chinese wall" between the news and entertainment functions came down a long time ago, and there's no ethical standard of conduct left anywhere (though some individuals do show signs now and then) in print, video, or radio, possibly with the exception of the Christian Science Monitor (which has it's own viewpoint, but at least it doesn't try to pass itself off as anything else).

If you do any advertising - you should do an ad that says "Learn what the media and the government AREN'T TELLING YOU. There's clear water and clean beaches in the Gulf of Mexico. There are sunny days and smiles all around. Just visit Mustang Island for your perfect vacation".

Don't get me wrong -- it's been a GREAT summer here. We have sold out 8 of our first 9 weekends, which (IMHO) is fabulous.

I'm only referring to this particular weekend -- the Fourth of July -- which (I am told) is SUPPOSED to be the busiest on the island. Instead, it's turning out to be the slowest.
 
I can see that you are frustrated. That's too bad. I know that this is your first year down there, and I hope things turn around fast. You know this as well as anyone, but up here in Iowa just let Ed Wilson predict a blizzard of biblical proportions, and everybody heads to Hy Vee to clear the shelves. I could understand some farmers out in the boonies stocking up before the blizzard hits, but people in town run to the grocery store and stock up like they are going to be snowed in for a week. This winter I am going to keep track on a calender, and see how many days that Ed doesn't have a blizzard in the seven day forecast.

Anyway, back to the coast, I saw a CNN reporter the other day standing on a beach somewhere in Texas holding up a rubber glove that she said had been used by someone on a cleanup crew as evidence of how bad it was down there. Holy cow, evidently she couldn't even come up with a tar ball to put along with it. That is really stretching it for a story.
 
I'm very sorry to hear that things are so slow right now. It's not fair to you and the others who rely on tourism.

My family and I rotate our annual vacations between the Gulf and the Bahamas and we were looking forward to visiting the Gulf this year. Until the oil disaster. Reports of oil washing ashore, etc. spooked us to Nassau. And I'm sure that we're just one family among millions who were led astray.
 
Sorry to hear Jay. There are parts of the Gulf Coast that are affected by the disaster, but I am thankful that yours is not one of them.

We had the equivalent of a Cat I hurricane blow through here one year and it was amazing. I had never seen anything like that ever before, and I've had close calls with tornadoes. I am glad Alex turned out to be a non-event, but better safe than sorry. After what I saw, I decided it takes a special kind of stupid to tangle with a storm like that. I certainly won't.

I hope that despite this the business is doing what you want and you are enjoying Texas as much as you thought you would. Based on what little I know about you and what little I know about Texas, it seemed a good fit.

What's funny is that a Category 1 hurricane is basically what has hit Iowa over and over again this year. http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/sshws.shtml

74 mph winds? That's just another day in the Midwest! :wink2:
 
Anyway, back to the coast, I saw a CNN reporter the other day standing on a beach somewhere in Texas holding up a rubber glove that she said had been used by someone on a cleanup crew as evidence of how bad it was down there. Holy cow, evidently she couldn't even come up with a tar ball to put along with it. That is really stretching it for a story.

In Texas? The reporter was reporting live from the oil spill -- in TEXAS?

Um, that's a pretty good trick, since there isn't any oil in the water here at all. :rolleyes2: Gotta love CNN!
 
It is funny how the winds of fortune blow for the tourist industry. The week before Christmas 1999 we went to the Yucatan bonefishing. We stayed in a fish camp called Pesca Maya, and we were the only ones there. The manager of the place said that most of his cabins were reserved by a corporation that was going to have a retreat there for some of their execs, and they canceled because they were afraid of Y2K. It was nice for us, but I kind of felt sorry for all the sad faces that were dividing up our tips.
 
In Texas? The reporter was reporting live from the oil spill -- in TEXAS?

Um, that's a pretty good trick, since there isn't any oil in the water here at all. :rolleyes2: Gotta love CNN!

I'm quite sure they said that she was reporting from Texas. Also, it was quite a while ago, when they were still trying to get the well capped. Hey, she had a glove, what more do you want?
 
My point is the over-hyped, end-of-the-world coverage for two non-events.

It stinks that your business is affected. It was a non-event in your location, but there were a number of fatalities where Alex landed in Mexico as a Category 2 with 105 mph winds and a 4-6 foot surge.

Much better to have a slow weekend than to get hit and be closed for the rest of the year I'd say.

I don't think too much of the Weather Channel. They used to be like Henny Penny with some useful information, but I think they've outlived their usefulness with the advent of internet sources. They sent people here last year for a snowstorm, and about all they did was have people on the edge of the Interstate sticking rulers in the snow, saying, "Yeah, it's really snowing now!" as if you couldn't tell that by looking out any window in town...
 
It is funny how the winds of fortune blow for the tourist industry. The week before Christmas 1999 we went to the Yucatan bonefishing. We stayed in a fish camp called Pesca Maya, and we were the only ones there. The manager of the place said that most of his cabins were reserved by a corporation that was going to have a retreat there for some of their execs, and they canceled because they were afraid of Y2K. It was nice for us, but I kind of felt sorry for all the sad faces that were dividing up our tips.

For sure -- it works both ways. In 2008, Iowa City was hit with catastrophic flooding. We sand-bagged, and for a few days our hotel was an island. No way in or out.

Then, the water receded, and all hell broke loose. Two of our biggest competitors were wiped out, and tons of folks arrived to help with the clean up. We went from despair to absolutely rolling in guests, virtually overnight, all thanks to a real weather catastrophe.

As a result, 2008 was our best year ever.
 
For the residents of coastal LA, MS, AL, and the panhandle of FL the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is far from being a non-event.

And for them the end is far from being in sight. Even if they stop the flow from the original blow out tomorrow.
 
Stories I'm seeing on-line (consider the source) are painting a gloomy picture for the future of CNN. Maybe there is justice in this world.

A friend in California a number of years ago was a co-owner of one of the San Jose TV stations. He was an engineering type and referred to the "news" department as the "newsies". It was NOT a term of endearment. :D
 
For the residents of coastal LA, MS, AL, and the panhandle of FL the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is far from being a non-event.

And for them the end is far from being in sight. Even if they stop the flow from the original blow out tomorrow.
I don't think Jay or anyone is minimizing the event in the gulf or the effect it is having. The point of the thread was to point out that by referencing it as a "gulf" event, the media has effectively killed any vacation business from Brownsville to the Keys. More to the point, since it has been the top story on every media outlet for 72 days, it quite probably has killed any nearterm recovery.
Now they're picking on Miami!
 
For the residents of coastal LA, MS, AL, and the panhandle of FL the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is far from being a non-event.

And for them the end is far from being in sight. Even if they stop the flow from the original blow out tomorrow.

No doubt, and you'll get no quarrel from me about that.

I just wish there was some way to effectively communicate that much (most?) of the Gulf is NOT being impacted by the oil at all. This is strictly an "East of Louisiana" thing.
 
I just wish there was some way to effectively communicate that much (most?) of the Gulf is NOT being impacted by the oil at all. This is strictly an "East of Louisiana" thing.
Doesn't Texas have a department of tourism? On the other hand there's karma. The minute they start gloating about the pristine Texas beaches the oil will head that way.
 
Doesn't Texas have a department of tourism? On the other hand there's karma. The minute they start gloating about the pristine Texas beaches the oil will head that way.

Actually, I don't think that's even possible, because of the currents that basically "turn" clockwise around the Gulf. The oil will continue to go East, and then possibly get picked up by the stream that goes up the East coast.

This is all great news for us, but in a country where most students can't find Mississippi on a map of the U.S., people aren't understanding the message.
 
Get in line and sue BP for loss of revenue and accompanying stress, get your million out of them as well.
 
Get in line and sue BP for loss of revenue and accompanying stress, get your million out of them as well.

If we were actually being impacted by the oil, that *might* make sense? Alas, we're being impacted by the impressions left by the likes of CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, rather than any actual damage caused by BP.

Thankfully, it looks like we're ending up having an okay weekend. Not sold out, for the first time in 2 months, but we're doing better than some of our neighbors on the island. (The next motel down the street -- a very nice place -- has 34 out of 55 rooms available! THAT is catastrophic...)
 
Don't get me wrong -- it's been a GREAT summer here. We have sold out 8 of our first 9 weekends, which (IMHO) is fabulous.

I'm only referring to this particular weekend -- the Fourth of July -- which (I am told) is SUPPOSED to be the busiest on the island. Instead, it's turning out to be the slowest.

Welcome to the service industry on the Gulf Coast.. Sometimes you take care of business.. sometimes business takes care of you...

With regards to the media... we even have a character on a local station called "Hurricane Wayne" for a reason...

Hurricane Season runs through November. Alex officially hit Mexico and was barely a hurricane. We usually have somewhere on the Texas coast get hit directly every few years.. and some years its much worse.

The oil spill is yet just another "complication" that isn't your fault, but is your problem.

It really might be fortuitous that you kept the Alexis, because it may serve the purpose of floating the Mustang Island property during the harder times.. If you guys take a direct hit, expect power to be out for over a month. Expect to be kept off the island for up to a week (and as a result not able to come back quick to mitigate water damage/mold until its too late)

Not trying to be negative.. Mustang island is a beautiful place.. but its also essentially a sand berm... a barrier island.
 
Welcome to the service industry on the Gulf Coast.. Sometimes you take care of business.. sometimes business takes care of you...

With regards to the media... we even have a character on a local station called "Hurricane Wayne" for a reason...

Hurricane Season runs through November. Alex officially hit Mexico and was barely a hurricane. We usually have somewhere on the Texas coast get hit directly every few years.. and some years its much worse.

The oil spill is yet just another "complication" that isn't your fault, but is your problem.

It really might be fortuitous that you kept the Alexis, because it may serve the purpose of floating the Mustang Island property during the harder times.. If you guys take a direct hit, expect power to be out for over a month. Expect to be kept off the island for up to a week (and as a result not able to come back quick to mitigate water damage/mold until its too late)

Not trying to be negative.. Mustang island is a beautiful place.. but its also essentially a sand berm... a barrier island.
'

Oh, don't we know it.

That's why insurance here is so essential -- and incredibly expensive.
 
If we were actually being impacted by the oil, that *might* make sense? Alas, we're being impacted by the impressions left by the likes of CNN, MSNBC and Fox News, rather than any actual damage caused by BP.

Thankfully, it looks like we're ending up having an okay weekend. Not sold out, for the first time in 2 months, but we're doing better than some of our neighbors on the island. (The next motel down the street -- a very nice place -- has 34 out of 55 rooms available! THAT is catastrophic...)

It's causal impact. BP Caused it which allowed CNN to scare people with it. Personally I wouldn't go within 100 miles of the GOM... it'll give you cancer and incite you to suicide....:eek:
 
This is all great news for us, but in a country where most students can't find Mississippi on a map of the U.S., people aren't understanding the message.

The bigger problem might be the media where most probably couldn't
find the Mississippi either.

:-/
 
The bigger problem might be the media where most probably couldn't
find the Mississippi either.

:-/

Well, there is that.

In Iowa -- not a state known for hyperbole or panic -- the weathermen have become increasingly shrill in their warnings as the people have become immune to the sound of their voices. You can only go to the "panic well" so many times before people ignore you completely, and I'm afraid that's what's happened.

At least partially as a result, whenever there is a thunderstorm approaching, all the Cedar Rapids stations interrupt their regular programing and become 24/7 panic-mongers.

Of course, the only logical explanation for this is that panic SELLS. Apparently more people tune in to watch the "Live -- from the rainstorm" coverage than will watch their normal shows. It's not doing anyone a service, however, to pointlessly ratchet up the fear to the point where simple-minded people run to the grocery store for "supplies" every time they hear thunder.

Now, of course, a major hurricane would be a different story altogether -- but I've spoken with plenty of "old-timers" on this island who say they NEVER evactuate, even when ordered to, simply because the predictions are always overblown. That is truly dangerous, and represents the real problem with all this hyped up coverage.
 
Well, there is that.

In Iowa -- not a state known for hyperbole or panic -- the weathermen have become increasingly shrill in their warnings as the people have become immune to the sound of their voices. You can only go to the "panic well" so many times before people ignore you completely, and I'm afraid that's what's happened.

At least partially as a result, whenever there is a thunderstorm approaching, all the Cedar Rapids stations interrupt their regular programing and become 24/7 panic-mongers.

Of course, the only logical explanation for this is that panic SELLS. Apparently more people tune in to watch the "Live -- from the rainstorm" coverage than will watch their normal shows. It's not doing anyone a service, however, to pointlessly ratchet up the fear to the point where simple-minded people run to the grocery store for "supplies" every time they hear thunder.

Now, of course, a major hurricane would be a different story altogether -- but I've spoken with plenty of "old-timers" on this island who say they NEVER evactuate, even when ordered to, simply because the predictions are always overblown. That is truly dangerous, and represents the real problem with all this hyped up coverage.

It was kind of silly here in Iowa last winter. Around Christmas, as you probably remember Jay, we got hit every night. I would watch the 10:00 weather, and Ed Wilson and Johnny Mac would be on a rampage. Things like "this is a major storm", "we've already gotten 4 inches and we expect eight more before it is over." It was like they were predicting the end of the world. "Dangerous wind chills," like everyone in Iowa doesn't have a winter coat, and doesn't go out in below zero weather every day of the week during the winter. So early every morning a tractor with a blade would come clearing our residential street and wake me up. I would go out, grab my big self propelled two stage snow blower, and go out with the rest of the neighbors to dig out. Forty five minutes max. That included the sidewalks and my next door neighbor's sidewalk.Then we would all go to work. The next night, Ed and John would be on the TV telling us that we were getting hit again. Like we are not used to snow in Iowa. After a while the big line was that it was getting really bad, no place to put the snow. Holy cow I thought. No kidding. My wife was in Las Vegas at a conference, and she was coming home at three in the afternoon one day. We got eleven inches of snow the night before. By the time two in the afternoon rolled around, I was doing 70 mph down the interstate on my way to Des Moines, no problem. The road was clear. If you are used to a certain kind of bad weather, it becomes a non-event.
 
Last edited:
In Iowa --
Speaking of geographically-challenged, a number of years ago I lived in Idaho for about a year. I had no idea how many people have no idea where that is and would get it mixed up with Iowa or Ohio. :confused:

Back to your regularly scheduled program...
 
Speaking of geographically-challenged, a number of years ago I lived in Idaho for about a year. I had no idea how many people have no idea where that is and would get it mixed up with Iowa or Ohio. :confused:

The obligatory New Yorker cover:

newyorker1.png
 
Speaking of geographically-challenged, a number of years ago I lived in Idaho for about a year. I had no idea how many people have no idea where that is and would get it mixed up with Iowa or Ohio. :confused:

Back to your regularly scheduled program...

I get the same when I tell people I'm from Nebraska. I mean, it is smack dab in the middle for crying out loud....
 
Well, I guess I spoke too soon. We're sold out at the Harbor Inn for tonight, and only have a couple left for tomorrow night. :thumbsup:

(Necessary Aviation Content: Just had a guy arrive, having flown his turbo-Dakota in from Colorado. That's a good, long flight...)

Thankfully, it appears that enough people have realized that there are bargains to be had on the island this weekend to offset the loss of "regulars"...

Nerve wracking, but better than the alternative...

BTW: We've now got a courtesy car here for y'all to use when you fly in, just like we have up at our other place in Iowa.
 
Last edited:
Was it someone from POA?

I don't know. He knew a fair amount about what we've done here, and up in Iowa -- but that could be from any number of sources.

He was eager to take a nap (naturally, after a looooong cross-country) in the A/C, take a dip, and grab some seafood. I'll chat with him more tomorrow, I suspect...
 
Well, I guess I spoke too soon. We're sold out at the Harbor Inn for tonight, and only have a couple left for tomorrow night. :thumbsup:

(Necessary Aviation Content: Just had a guy arrive, having flown his turbo-Dakota in from Colorado. That's a good, long flight...)

Thankfully, it appears that enough people have realized that there are bargains to be had on the island this weekend to offset the loss of "regulars"...

Nerve wracking, but better than the alternative...

BTW: We've now got a courtesy car here for y'all to use when you fly in, just like we have up at our other place in Iowa.

I'd be willing to bet I got a ride in that plane from Steamboat to Denver...:cornut:
 
All I'll say is that it was a lot of flying in three days and that the aircraft appears to be re-usable at this point. Closer inspection may reveal the folly in that conclusion but I sincerely believe it won't...

Anybody check the weather across Tejas & Oklahoma yesterday?
 
Back
Top