NC19143 Wrote
If a person with an A&P certificate that is working in a facility that does maintenance checks on heavy aircraft and never works on a small aircraft, should be sorted out and limited as to what they can do.
I'd say that ANYONE working in any aircraft maintenence capacity is limited to knowing what one person can possibly know, and by what they have been asked to do before. The range and scope of technologies it's reasonable to expect to encounter in aviation will always be beyond what one person can know for small or large aircraft.
The most dangerous people will be those that have some credible level of skill and knowledge, but somehow unaccountably one day become the world book of knowledge, all knowing in all things.
In my opinion, everyone needs to be as objective and realistic as possible when evaluating their proficency at any specific task.
As unspecific as that is, that's really the only thing that makes sense.
This thread is a good review though.
I could interpret my own qualifications and claim competency as an A&P for a lot of work (at different levels), despite the fact I don't do any wrench turning now. Over 20-30 years, I've done my fair share of work in 5-6 very different aviation environments, as an A&P and engineer. On most days now, I develop avionics rework DWGs, write the modification procedures and ultimately the test procedures that go in the AMM for TCAS & Mode S Transponder systems on big jets. There are some jobs I might consider tackling in GA and some I wouldn't touch.
Can A&Ps knowledgeable on 20 yr old airplanes handle diesel engine work, composite structural work, light turbine work? I've watched A&Ps that couldn't fathom the landing gear indication light circuit on a simple turboprop twin. How may A&Ps would should light a torch and attempt a weld repair?
At one point I was the lead man for the overnight maintenence crew on a fleet of 10 Jetstreean 32s. I was working for a part 145 repair station. They had the maint contract for a local airline feeder. We handled the line and the heavy checks.
Some of the guys on the crew had been turning wrenches since the days of the Connie (they refused the lead position because they didn't want the hastle). Others were just out of school (in one case waiting for their first hearing).
The only guy that never asked for help/opinions, maybe from QA, maybe from the the BAE rep, research help, teammate help, even lead help, was the guy waiting on his hearing (for leaving a cotter key off after a tire change in his previous job - no one was killed when it came off).
I couldn't get him to even look in the AMM for something simple like installing a wiper blade! They line up better when you park the system. Everyone in the operation warned me about that lad.
As a side note, the boss hired him because he had the factory training, and still had his A&P, stipulations in the contract.