What made you choose to switch to the Piper over the Cessna? What are the things, I may want that would need to be added/upgraded? I am trying to learn as much as I can before making such an investment.
i bought PA 28 just based on my research, i had never been in a low wing before. this is my personal opinion (and remind you, i am not responsible for any war that is about to start over low vs high wing)...
PA 28 is easier to land, especially in cross winds, which is always the case where i am based
it doesnt stall, it mushes down, doesnt matter how much you want it to stall - PA-28 181 semi-tapered wing
i wanted to learn in something that i will fly
sitting on the wing is far better than hanging from one
PA handles turbulence really well
i love to see the runway while turning base to final
just like u i didnt wanted to dump 10k on rental - its a wise choice if u stick to it
about cost, i have numbers if you want, if u calculate just based on hrs, yah your own plane is cheaper (assuming u fly a lot, as on today, i do), however, tomorrow if i need a overhaul, its 25k rt there, if i was renting, all i need to do is walk to the FBO and say...dude good luck
aircraft ownership is not cheap. apart from hangar and insurance, there is annual, upgrades that you will want (trust me, you will), and anything that might break without any notice whatsoever. however, there are a million things, some are tangible, some are not, aircraft ownership makes sense and renting doesnt - ONLY if you keep flying. i was committed, it worked out for me (so far), might not work out for others.