Ken Ibold
Final Approach
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2005
- Messages
- 5,889
- Location
- Jacksonville, Florida
- Display Name
Display name:
Ken Ibold
Why is it that EVERYTHING these days is who you know or who you've ticked off, rather than what you do?
Case 1: As you may recall, my son plays little league baseball. He was second on the team in average (.648), led the team in runs scored, second in RBI, first in both fielding percentage and fielding skill, and a real team leader. However, the coach who selected the all-star team bypassed him, I THINK because we beat his team (badly) in the playoffs. (And in that game Parker hit a homer.) The coach selected only one player from my team (vs 3 from his own) and it was a kid I only halfheartedly nominated who is a good hitter but a truly awful fielder.
Case 2: My daughter -- 10 years old and finishing 6th grade -- won second place in the state science fair (the ONLY 6th grader to do so in the state) and had a straight A average. Yet at today's 6th grade awards thing, she did NOT get the science award. That was given to the daughter of the PTA president. She did NOT get recognition of any kind despite the fact that she was the only 6th grader to get straight A's all year (very tough school). The Math Team got medals. The History Fair participants got recognized. The student who got "student of the year" was the son of last year's PTA president.
Now, but there are two dynamics here. First, the whole "awards" thing has blown up in the name of self-esteem such that at a lot of these competitions the trophies are bigger than the kids. (So why does it tick me off they got bypassed?) Second, I probably am biased as a proud papa and there are probably some sour grapes here. But time and again I see people who deserve recognition passed over, while well-connected folks bask. What a disincentive to work hard!
I guess the old saw really is true that it ain't what you know, it's who you know. I just resent it when adults take it out on the kids.
Rant off.
Case 1: As you may recall, my son plays little league baseball. He was second on the team in average (.648), led the team in runs scored, second in RBI, first in both fielding percentage and fielding skill, and a real team leader. However, the coach who selected the all-star team bypassed him, I THINK because we beat his team (badly) in the playoffs. (And in that game Parker hit a homer.) The coach selected only one player from my team (vs 3 from his own) and it was a kid I only halfheartedly nominated who is a good hitter but a truly awful fielder.
Case 2: My daughter -- 10 years old and finishing 6th grade -- won second place in the state science fair (the ONLY 6th grader to do so in the state) and had a straight A average. Yet at today's 6th grade awards thing, she did NOT get the science award. That was given to the daughter of the PTA president. She did NOT get recognition of any kind despite the fact that she was the only 6th grader to get straight A's all year (very tough school). The Math Team got medals. The History Fair participants got recognized. The student who got "student of the year" was the son of last year's PTA president.
Now, but there are two dynamics here. First, the whole "awards" thing has blown up in the name of self-esteem such that at a lot of these competitions the trophies are bigger than the kids. (So why does it tick me off they got bypassed?) Second, I probably am biased as a proud papa and there are probably some sour grapes here. But time and again I see people who deserve recognition passed over, while well-connected folks bask. What a disincentive to work hard!
I guess the old saw really is true that it ain't what you know, it's who you know. I just resent it when adults take it out on the kids.
Rant off.
Last edited: