I followed the keynote with mac rumors live, but now that the reality-distortion field has subsided, I'm not sure I agree the iPhone is a revolution. Don't get me wrong; it is wicked cool.
Here's where I'm coming from: my Sony Ericsson
S710a has a cool form factor and very nice screen, but it feels like a brick in my pocket at 137 grams! The SE calendar shows a month at a time, and if a day has appointments, it's date is bolded. Trouble is, it's hard to tell the difference between bold and non-bold days. So, I would looooove something like the OS X experience on my mobile device.
I recently tried the SE
K790a. It was smaller and weighed 115 g, which I could tell was much lighter. Calendar still sucked. Other gimmicky stuff. No way I could justify the $400 unlocked price tag to stay with T-Mobile.
My current test subject is the
Nokia E70, because I was curious about the flip-out keyboard. It (and the
E61) may be the closest hardware-wise to the iPhone, including WiFi & BT. Symbian is not bad, calendar is nicer, works with iSync, and the built-in Opera web browser works well and is similar technology to Safari. The E70 is slightly lighter at 127g, but the E61 (and WiFi-less
E62 from Cingular) are a porky 144g. I may try one of the multitudinous N-series offerings next: smaller still and come in a variety of packages.
Size-wise, the iPhone is almost identical to "serious" devices like the
Motorola Q, the E62, the
Treo 680, and of course, the ubiquitious Blackberries. So, the iPhone could also be a business-class contender. It's the only one of this group that has WiFi. However, the hot new
Pearl might have the drop on the iPhone for size.
Yet, that's not what Apples are for. You've got drool-worthy phone software in an absolute block of a piece of hardware. Look how many people sold their firstborns to get the Razr, even though it's software sucked. Thin & flip are in. Phones are almost a fashion statement. Yes, Steve-o did it once with the iPod. I'm not totally convinced on the touchscreen either. I find it technologically cool that they can detect multiple-finger gestures, but "typing" on a glass surface just feels weird. Much different than twirling on that round iPod dial.
It has no memory slot, but I think that's a non-issue. Built-in memories of today's phones are all in the 64MB or less range. SD cards get you up to 2GB, and Sony's Memory Stick Duo Pro just got upgraded to 8GB this month, so the iPhone's 4 or 8 GB should be sufficient for now.
However, the $499/$599 price tag and a switch to Cingular are not.
-Rich
P.S. Ask me again in June when they become available.