HSI test question

bflynn

bflynn

Final Approach
Joined
Apr 24, 2012
Messages
9,821
Location
KTTA
Display Name
Display name:
Brian Flynn
Figure 110 - question is, what general direction are you relative to the station?

The selected radial is 060, from. You're flying 300 and the selected radial is to your left. Couldn't you be either NE or NW?
fig110.jpg Fig110 Drawing.jpg
 
I say A for two reasons:
1. If you were NW wouldn’t the To/From indicator be flipped?
2. It’s only two dots off. No way you’re at position B with only two dots deflection.
 
The CDI displacement is 6 degrees SE which means if R060 is selected you are 6 degrees NW of R060. Keep in mind the maximum deflection is +/- 10 of the selected radial. You are 054 (NE) from the station. Turn your diagram so 060 is at 12 o’clock and you will see it.

Here a site for a CDI simulator.

http://www.luizmonteiro.com/Learning_HSI_Sim.aspx
 
Last edited:
Practice practice practice!! I found the key to learning these is just to keep doing them!!
 
At position "B" the CDI would be fully deflected, and any farther west than the 330 radial, the ambiguity indicator would be a TO.

As a side note, I don't see the purpose in drawing a line along 300°, it only obfuscates the problem.
 
dmspilot said:
At position "B" the CDI would be fully deflected, and any farther west than the 330 radial, the ambiguity indicator would be a TO.

As a side note, I don't see the purpose in drawing a line along 300°, it only obfuscates the problem.
Click to expand...

It’s telling what direction you are flying.
 
teejayevans said:
It’s telling what direction you are flying.
Click to expand...

I find, in general, the “direction you are flying” serves as a distractor in VOR/HSI orientation problems.

Here 060° is set in the “OBS”. Mentally turn the little plane to be heading 060°.

Then the “FROM - Fly Right” indication is consistent with plane A, regardless of heading.

At least, that works for me, and though it’s been a while, I’m pretty sure this is not something I’ve ever missed on a written.
 
Last edited:
The problem with these types of questions is that they assume the pilot was materialized at that point in space instead of flying there, or had been knocked unconscious a half hour earlier and just recovered. It's the way most of the VOR and HSI questions work, which is what makes them difficult for a lot of folks. No context like you have when actually using the equipment. So, find the best way you can to make it make sense to you.

On this one, I like the responses which point out that there is only a 2-3 dot deflection of the 10-degree full deflection needle, placing you only 4-6 degrees off the centerline. Whether you go the long way to say which radial you are actually on or simply, like @bluesky74656, simply say, there's no way it's B, doesn't matter much to either the test or the real world..
 
dmspilot said:
The airplane symbols do that. The line has no purpose.
Click to expand...

They don’t give you the degrees. The line does that.
Are we really complaining the question gives us too much information? Are they trying to make it a bit harder, maybe, it is a test question after all.
 
Clip4 said:
The CDI displacement is 6 degrees SE which means if R060 is selected you are 6 degrees NW of R060. Keep in mind the maximum deflection is +/- 10 of the selected radial. You are 054 (NE) from the station. Turn your diagram so 060 is at 12 o’clock and you will see it.

Here a site for a CDI simulator.

http://www.luizmonteiro.com/Learning_HSI_Sim.aspx
Click to expand...

Yeah. Another thing that you can do is, in as much as the Heading is not pertinent to the question asked, is mentally turn the plane to heading 060. The course selector is on 060, the white arrow (To/From indicator) is behind you so you are tracking away from the Station. Now you have yourself paralleling the selected radial and you see that have to 'turn into the needle' and your only a couple dots away. You gotta be airplane A and it is Northeast of the Station. Get something like a square piece of paper. Put one edge on the 060 radial on the diagram. Now move the corner down to the Station. Airplane B is very close to 90 degrees off. The needle would probably be very close to swinging from stop to stop and the To/From would be changing

EDIT: if i'd a kept reading i'd a seen this was already answered.
 
Last edited:
FastEddieB said:
I find, in general, the “direction you are flying” serves as a distractor in VOR/HSI orientation problems.

Here 060° is set in the “OBS”. Mentally turn the little plane to be heading 060°.

Then the “FROM - Fly Right” indication is consistent with plane A, regardless of heading.

At least, that works for me, and though it’s been a while, I’m pretty sure this is not something I’ve ever missed on a written.
Click to expand...

Yeah. I to find that mentally turning the plane to a logical direction is a quick way to visualize these 'where are you' type questions
 
teejayevans said:
They don’t give you the degrees. The line does that.
Are we really complaining the question gives us too much information? Are they trying to make it a bit harder, maybe, it is a test question after all.
Click to expand...

OP's drawing is not part of the "question", so no, "we" are not complaining about the question giving too much information. I am complaining that is not clear what information the 300° line is supposed to be giving and now that I know what it's for I am complaining that it's redundant.
 
The problem I have with these types of questions is that they drop you into these scenarios cold. Very seldom is your situational awareness so poor that you don’t have some idea where you are to begin with.

But I understand why they do it.
 
I think my phone is acting up, because I don’t see a magenta line :)
 
You're NE of the station, flying NW. Once you are past the abeam point of the VOR, the flag will flip to FROM.
 
dmspilot said:
OP's drawing is not part of the "question", so no, "we" are not complaining about the question giving too much information. I am complaining that is not clear what information the 300° line is supposed to be giving and now that I know what it's for I am complaining that it's redundant.
Click to expand...

It's the way I draw it. A square with a line and the arrow either pointing from or to for the radial, then a line showing the course heading so I know the general course the plane is on. From there, orient the drawing with the HSI, check for reverse sensing and then move it so the line is where the bearing is. This works for me. If it bothers you, erase the heading line.

A is the answer I came up with too, but it's taken a while for the difference between degrees and distance from the station to make sense why.

I have virtually no experience with actually using an HSI. This works until I get experience and can do it in my head.
 
bflynn said:
I have virtually no experience with actually using an HSI.
Click to expand...

My suggestion then is to turn the diagram so that the course selector is at the top - 060° in this case, and to ignore or actually block out the little plane in the center. Then view it as a conventional CDI.

Give me a few and I’ll try to come up with the OP’s diagram as an example.
 
Last edited:
Here you go:

45950014212_58e932f9a7_z.jpg


I think that helps in these cases. And in this case confirms my assertion about it showing FROM.
 
It might help understand how an HSI prevents "reverse sensing" by looking at the OP's diagram with a change or two. Airplane "A" could be in the midst of doing a procedure turn where it isn't necessary to change the OBS when reversing course, like this:

HSI.jpg​
EDIT: Only the To/Fr indication would be flipped from that shown.
 
Last edited:
FastEddieB said:
Here you go:

45950014212_58e932f9a7_z.jpg


I think that helps in these cases. And in this case confirms my assertion about it showing FROM.
Click to expand...

Paging @bflynn who started this and said "...I have virtually no experience with actually using an HSI. This works until I get experience and can do it in my head..."

This is a way to do it.
 
Yes, I am still reading.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top