PaulS
Touchdown! Greaser!
Congrats @benyflyguy it's a great feeling isn't it?
Passed my IFR checkride!!!
The only time you have to go to your filed alternate is lost comms. I say that, yet if ZZZ is a better option, you can do anything you want in an emergency.The scenario: You filed to XXX with YYY as your alternate. En route to XXX, you lose comms and you never get VMC. You shoot an approach to XXX but it's below minimums so you go missed. At that point, aren't you required to fly to YYY (assuming you never hit VMC between XXX and YYY) even though ZZZ might have been a better option?
Even without an emergency, I don't see anything in 91.185 or elsewhere that requires you to go to your filed alternate.The only time you have to go to your filed alternate is lost comms. I say that, yet if ZZZ is a better option, you can do anything you want in an emergency.