My first trip to Bahamas (thread is on here somewhere) was KFPR->MYEF (then I island hopped a bit). I bought the AOPA guide, watched some youtubes (some guy in an Aztec laid it out very well), got FlashPass (worth every penny). VFR down, IFR back dead simple. I picked MYEF because it was away from the busy-ness of the bigger places, it was AOE, and Odessy down there is fantastic.
But I went in March. I went to a conference in Orlando once in August - I'm never going back south during the summer again. I'm of the North, and the North remembers.