1 faa failure and two 121 failures, how to move forward
- Thread starter Johnny delmi
- Start date
- Joined
- Jun 11, 2015
- Messages
- 4,111
- Display Name
Display name:
Piperonca
Dad was a primary flight instructor for the Army Air Corps during World War II. One of his duties was to give a final evaluation ride to student pilots who were about to flunk out of the program. I don’t remember him saying he ever lost one of them. Some went on to senior ranks in what became the Air Force. His method was first, treat them with respect. Next, he told them don’t worry about criteria, just do their very best. It always worked.
hindsight2020
Final Approach
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2010
- Messages
- 6,997
- Display Name
Display name:
hindsight2020
*TLDR warning*
Yeah, it's an uncomfortable and tough job, but someone has to do it. I'm ultimately not ordered into duty to be people's friend; my non-evaluator peers love passing the buck on that, and lord knows I'm never in the "favorite IP" list as a result, ever.
Evaluating is actually rather easy to defend on the personality front, because you're a ghost in cold mic, so they can't accuse you of personality conflicts in the airplane. So this is more about the IP/non-evaluator role. To be clear, I'm not terse in the airplane, which is one of the more common complaints aggrieved students have against instructors. Their more common complaint I've faced is that I hold the line; they see it as "grading hard". They don't complain about it per se, they just try to tone-police you about misc grievances on the ground in order to lash out against you (meanie was late to the brief, he was too emphatic on the debrief, etc).
The uncomfortable reality is that some of my peers just don't want to grade to the line. Some don't really take this job seriously, which bothers me, but most within that cohort actually care but just don't want to lose their affability. Either way, they just expect those of us type-casted as "grim reapers" to act as safety nets/glovesaves and catch these weak swimmers before they're allowed to kill someone. I've been pigeonholed into that stereotype at work by now. Did I mention life ain't fair? But that's between me and my peers.
BL, I treat everybody with respect, and most importantly, I provide the same objective and neutral evaluation whether the guy is top stick or about to get washed out. Insufferably consistent line, and I'm proud of that. Not every baby turtle makes it to the ocean, and life ain't fair. Game here is Chess, it ain't checkers.
Yeah, it's an uncomfortable and tough job, but someone has to do it. I'm ultimately not ordered into duty to be people's friend; my non-evaluator peers love passing the buck on that, and lord knows I'm never in the "favorite IP" list as a result, ever.
Evaluating is actually rather easy to defend on the personality front, because you're a ghost in cold mic, so they can't accuse you of personality conflicts in the airplane. So this is more about the IP/non-evaluator role. To be clear, I'm not terse in the airplane, which is one of the more common complaints aggrieved students have against instructors. Their more common complaint I've faced is that I hold the line; they see it as "grading hard". They don't complain about it per se, they just try to tone-police you about misc grievances on the ground in order to lash out against you (meanie was late to the brief, he was too emphatic on the debrief, etc).
The uncomfortable reality is that some of my peers just don't want to grade to the line. Some don't really take this job seriously, which bothers me, but most within that cohort actually care but just don't want to lose their affability. Either way, they just expect those of us type-casted as "grim reapers" to act as safety nets/glovesaves and catch these weak swimmers before they're allowed to kill someone. I've been pigeonholed into that stereotype at work by now. Did I mention life ain't fair? But that's between me and my peers.
BL, I treat everybody with respect, and most importantly, I provide the same objective and neutral evaluation whether the guy is top stick or about to get washed out. Insufferably consistent line, and I'm proud of that. Not every baby turtle makes it to the ocean, and life ain't fair. Game here is Chess, it ain't checkers.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jun 11, 2015
- Messages
- 4,111
- Display Name
Display name:
Piperonca
Kudos to OP for overcoming initial obstacles and persevering. My comments were a reflection on my father's Jedi Mind Trick to put students at ease. Thereby he could tell actually how well they could fly. And once that was done, it was an open field, forgive the expression. Teaching primary in Stearmans was more loosey goosey than today. Same problem, though: how to retain good students (cadets) who needed to get over some psychological hump, while eliminating the incorrigible. My uncle was also an instructor at the same facility, and he specialized in the ones who were expected to have no chance, and just needed the final ride as a formality.
Hat's off to anyone instructing/evaluating/flying in today's military. There's more going on, and it happens faster. Not a job for the faint of heart, or long of tooth. Hindsight brings great insight. Love reading his stuff.
Hat's off to anyone instructing/evaluating/flying in today's military. There's more going on, and it happens faster. Not a job for the faint of heart, or long of tooth. Hindsight brings great insight. Love reading his stuff.