RJM62
Touchdown! Greaser!
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2007
- Messages
- 13,157
- Location
- Upstate New York
- Display Name
Display name:
Geek on the Hill
Here's a mini-review of a service mentioned in another thread. This is based on about two hours of possessing the device, of which an hour was spent trying to activate it.
Activation
Activation was a pain, for three reasons:
1. There's a Catch-22 in the activation process. To activate the device, you need a Verizon Wireless login. To create the VZW login, they need to send a PIN code to the device. But the device can't receive text messages until it's activated -- and even then, apparently only from Verizon. I couldn't SMS it.
In addition, the messages can only be viewed from within the device's Web interface, which isn't accessible until the device is activated, which requires that the VZW account be established, which requires the PIN be sent to the device, which can't receive the PIN until it's activated. Milo Minderbinder would be proud.
2. It's rather difficult to get through to a human when you call because the prompts are rather ambiguous and geared toward phones, not hotspots. I finally chose "Device Support" or something along those lines, and the rep was able to send me a PIN by email.
3. The SIM card number was different from the one that was printed on the box and that Verizon had on record, and it took the rep a while to get that one to activate. Maybe they have special SIM cards for unlimited service, but never bothered to re-label the box.
Minor Annoyances
While the rep was trying to provision the SIM card, the call was cut off. However, the device started working while I was cussing. Perhaps it needs to hear the correct combination of cuss words in order to activate.
There also was a message waiting in the device's Web interface asking me to rate the rep's help, but no way to respond to it.
Another minor annoyance was that I just received the device today, but they started the monthly billing cycle the day I placed the order. So I lost two days while waiting for it.
How Well Does it Work?
As for the actual service, it's not horrible:
That's with four bars out of five.
I know VZW is capable of higher speeds than that here. I used to get about 50 Mbps on one of my phones. But that wasn't with unlimited service. My guess it that they throttle the speed on unlimited to keep it truly unlimited. That's fair. Wireless bandwidth is cheap, but it's not free.
But hey, at 15 Mbps, it's not horrible. I remember back when speeds like that were just a pipe dream. And besides, I wanted this mainly for Internet failover. I can work with 15 Mbps.
Device / Router Functionality
I received the MHS900L. There's also an MHS7730L which is more advanced and more expensive, but it was out of stock when I placed my order. I suppose I can upgrade if I ever need to.
The device has one tiny screen that provides very little information, but it does provide signal strength and a few other very important pieces of information (such as the SSID and password). It has no Ethernet. I may or may not do some sort of WiFi-to-WAN thing to create a seamless failover system. I suppose a bridge and a dual-WAN router would do it.
There may also be dual-WAN routers that allow WiFi for one of the WAN sources. I haven't checked. Or there may be software for my work computer that switches from Ethernet to WiFi when the Ethernet adapter loses Internet. Or maybe I can write such software and retire a wealthy man.
I haven't tested the device's own routing abilities. I don't suppose they're very advanced considering the device's size and purpose. But the lady who signed me up said it could manage devices like network printers as long as they're WiFi-enabled. She also said it could connect a maximum of 15 devices, but the documentation says 8. Possibly there was a firmware update at some point.
Video Streaming
I haven't tried streaming video other than a few HD YouTube videos (which worked fine), but streaming is limited to 1080p, according to VZW. That's okay. So is my television. In fact, I may hook up the Roku to this device just so I'm using it for something between Internet outages. It also will reduce my usage on Sparrow Fart Telephone, who supposedly has a cap, which I pretty much always exceed, but who have never throttled me or billed me for an overage.
VPN
AirVPN works fine over the service. I don't know about any others.
Summary
It's too soon for me to make a recommendation other than to say that if you have a good VZW signal and you don't have any other way to get decent Internet, it's probably worth a try. They discounted the device to $50.00 for me (and probably everyone else), the service is $65.00 / month with auto-pay ($70.00 without), and there's no contract; so if your other Interweb options are crappy, you're not risking too much by trying this one.
The other logical use is probably more in line with what the service is designed for, and that's mobile Internet. That might be a good deal for pilots or others who travel a lot, and who prefer laptops to phones or tablets.
Rich
Activation
Activation was a pain, for three reasons:
1. There's a Catch-22 in the activation process. To activate the device, you need a Verizon Wireless login. To create the VZW login, they need to send a PIN code to the device. But the device can't receive text messages until it's activated -- and even then, apparently only from Verizon. I couldn't SMS it.
In addition, the messages can only be viewed from within the device's Web interface, which isn't accessible until the device is activated, which requires that the VZW account be established, which requires the PIN be sent to the device, which can't receive the PIN until it's activated. Milo Minderbinder would be proud.
2. It's rather difficult to get through to a human when you call because the prompts are rather ambiguous and geared toward phones, not hotspots. I finally chose "Device Support" or something along those lines, and the rep was able to send me a PIN by email.
3. The SIM card number was different from the one that was printed on the box and that Verizon had on record, and it took the rep a while to get that one to activate. Maybe they have special SIM cards for unlimited service, but never bothered to re-label the box.
Minor Annoyances
While the rep was trying to provision the SIM card, the call was cut off. However, the device started working while I was cussing. Perhaps it needs to hear the correct combination of cuss words in order to activate.
There also was a message waiting in the device's Web interface asking me to rate the rep's help, but no way to respond to it.
Another minor annoyance was that I just received the device today, but they started the monthly billing cycle the day I placed the order. So I lost two days while waiting for it.
How Well Does it Work?
As for the actual service, it's not horrible:
That's with four bars out of five.
I know VZW is capable of higher speeds than that here. I used to get about 50 Mbps on one of my phones. But that wasn't with unlimited service. My guess it that they throttle the speed on unlimited to keep it truly unlimited. That's fair. Wireless bandwidth is cheap, but it's not free.
But hey, at 15 Mbps, it's not horrible. I remember back when speeds like that were just a pipe dream. And besides, I wanted this mainly for Internet failover. I can work with 15 Mbps.
Device / Router Functionality
I received the MHS900L. There's also an MHS7730L which is more advanced and more expensive, but it was out of stock when I placed my order. I suppose I can upgrade if I ever need to.
The device has one tiny screen that provides very little information, but it does provide signal strength and a few other very important pieces of information (such as the SSID and password). It has no Ethernet. I may or may not do some sort of WiFi-to-WAN thing to create a seamless failover system. I suppose a bridge and a dual-WAN router would do it.
There may also be dual-WAN routers that allow WiFi for one of the WAN sources. I haven't checked. Or there may be software for my work computer that switches from Ethernet to WiFi when the Ethernet adapter loses Internet. Or maybe I can write such software and retire a wealthy man.
I haven't tested the device's own routing abilities. I don't suppose they're very advanced considering the device's size and purpose. But the lady who signed me up said it could manage devices like network printers as long as they're WiFi-enabled. She also said it could connect a maximum of 15 devices, but the documentation says 8. Possibly there was a firmware update at some point.
Video Streaming
I haven't tried streaming video other than a few HD YouTube videos (which worked fine), but streaming is limited to 1080p, according to VZW. That's okay. So is my television. In fact, I may hook up the Roku to this device just so I'm using it for something between Internet outages. It also will reduce my usage on Sparrow Fart Telephone, who supposedly has a cap, which I pretty much always exceed, but who have never throttled me or billed me for an overage.
VPN
AirVPN works fine over the service. I don't know about any others.
Summary
It's too soon for me to make a recommendation other than to say that if you have a good VZW signal and you don't have any other way to get decent Internet, it's probably worth a try. They discounted the device to $50.00 for me (and probably everyone else), the service is $65.00 / month with auto-pay ($70.00 without), and there's no contract; so if your other Interweb options are crappy, you're not risking too much by trying this one.
The other logical use is probably more in line with what the service is designed for, and that's mobile Internet. That might be a good deal for pilots or others who travel a lot, and who prefer laptops to phones or tablets.
Rich