Tesla Hit & Run - SOLVED!!! (long)

FastEddieB

FastEddieB

Touchdown! Greaser!
Joined
Oct 14, 2013
Messages
11,542
Location
Lenoir City, TN/Mineral Bluff, GA
Display Name
Display name:
Fast Eddie B
In case you missed it, buried in another Tesla thread was a hit and run on our 6-week-old Model 3.

https://www.pilotsofamerica.com/community/threads/tesla-model-3-finally.134268/page-14#post-3230784

Here's a summary of how we caught the guy.

The Tesla has an array of cameras front, rear, and 2 on each side, constantly recording. Our car had just stopped at a red light which had just turned red when a car turning swung wide and sideswiped us and fled:


We pulled the USB stick and downloaded the videos from the car's cameras and with the separate dashcam we use. Even going frame-by-frame it was just not possible to make out the tag number. One example here:

51969350138_457eca2eaf_o.png


I emailed the files to my son-in-law and he used some frame-by-frame video processing software to come up with a full Tennessee tag # which checked back to a 2010 Nissan Altima, pretty consistent with the fleeing car.

I gave that info to the deputy who handled the accident and our insurance company. The officer said the tag checked back to an address in the City of Knoxville, and his supervisor wouldn't let him go that far out of his zone, and that we'd need to get a city officer to follow up. I called and they said they didn't have the manpower to handle accidents occurring outside their city, but that a county officer surely had the jurisdiction to do so. I contacted the Deputy and he said he'd go by and attempt to make contact with the owner of the vehicle.

While all that was transpiring, our insurance company was tracking down the tag info themselves and found the vehicle had just been insured by another company the morning of the accident. Yesterday that insurance sent me an online claim form that had the name of their insured. Karen and I searched Facebook for the name and came up with someone of that name who had posted this:

51968875363_ff1914d1d9_c.jpg


Gotcha!

Late yesterday the deputy informed me he had made contact with the owner, who confessed to leaving the scene of the accident and got a citation for the same.

Kind of amazing how it all worked out. Big thanks to my son-in-law - without his help it would have likely been a dead end. The other driver's company has an internal investigation going on regarding the coincidence of insurance purchased that very day and the nature of the hit-and-run. That may delay getting our car fixed for a bit, but its functionally fine so not that big a deal. Will follow up as things proceed.
 
Love it when a plan comes together.!!

Reckon the other drivers insurance company will push being past the stop line.?? I am guessing the leaving the scene part my increase his premiums a lot, if not outright cancellation of policy.

And what a dofus for putting it on ''social media''...
 
That guy is in serious doo-doo. What possesses people to post something like that? Dumber than dumb.
 
Zeldman said:
Reckon the other drivers insurance company will push being past the stop line.??
Click to expand...

Maybe. I didn't really notice it until looking at the photos and videos. And an intersection is normally defined as the area within the lateral lines formed by the intersecting roads, and I was in fact clear of the intersection. In retrospect, I could have "run" the yellow and been OK - it was conservatively stopping in a marginal situation that put me where I was. And if you think about it, same set of circumstances with me short of the stop line and the Nissan would have struck me nearly head on, causing a LOT more damage, and maybe injury, so there's that. In the end I think it's clear that where my vehicle was stopped was not a contributing factor in the accident. His car swinging wide crossing into my lane was.
 
FastEddieB said:
Big thanks to my son-in-law - without his help it would have likely been a dead end.
Click to expand...
Also give credit to the TESLA for recording the event. Of course though, the Tesla haters will say that an ICE car could do that too. Probably, but then, why don't they?
 
Last edited:
JOhnH said:
Also give credit to the TESLA for recording the event. Of course though, the Tesla haters will say that an ICE car could do that too. Probably, but then, why don't then?
Click to expand...

The Kenwood head-unit in my Excursion will do it if I wanted it to. Has inputs for 4 cameras, and I currently have two (front/rear). I could add side view cameras or dash cam and have it record to flash memory. It's not difficult to do if someone wants to do it. As it is, I'd only have video of my wife backing into her coworker's car, lol.
 
Glad it worked out, Eddie, and I hope you're able to have your Tesla repaired soon.

Pretty good odds that the guy was under the influence, but of course by the time they got to him it was too late for any proof. Did you look up his name on the FAA website to see if he's a pilot? :)
 
Salty said:
That guy is in serious doo-doo...
Click to expand...
Maybe. A driver crossed a ~20' grass median colliding with my wife almost head on totaling her minivan. The guy drove away despite two blown tires, shattered windows and a mortally wounded car. He drove a mile or so down the road then turned into a neighborhood parking as far in the back as he could with the damaged side of his car facing woods. I guess he hoped to have the car towed before it could be found and connected to the accident. He was caught b/c a resident reported the car as it was pretty obvious what was going down. The police asked if we wanted to press charges. Maybe b/c my wife and young children were in the car, I said hell yes. About 6 months later we received a note charges were dropped b/c the county had more important matters to pursue.
 
Mahneuvers said:
Maybe. A driver crossed a ~20' grass median colliding with my wife almost head on totaling her minivan. The guy drove away despite two blown tires, shattered windows and a mortally wounded car. He drove a mile or so down the road then turned into a neighborhood parking as far in the back as he could with the damaged side of his car facing woods. I guess he hoped to have the car towed before it could be found and connected to the accident. He was caught b/c a resident reported the car as it was pretty obvious what was going down. The police asked if we wanted to press charges. Maybe b/c my wife and young children were in the car, I said hell yes. About 6 months later we received a note charges were dropped b/c the county had more important matters to pursue.
Click to expand...
Man, that’s wrong. Sorry to hear that. That just provides incentive to run. There’s no downside. Makes me mad.
 
Salty said:
Man, that’s wrong. Sorry to hear that. That just provides incentive to run. There’s no downside. Makes me mad.
Click to expand...
I guess the police really are being defunded. And some people (criminals) are ok with that.
 
JOhnH said:
I guess the police really are being defunded. And some people (criminals) are ok with that.
Click to expand...
What’s really sad is I’m sure they’d prosecute him if he hadn’t run. Assuming it was dui
 
FastEddieB said:
In retrospect, I could have "run" the yellow and been OK
Click to expand...

Around my part of the woods you d that and you will be rear ended by at least 1 car, maybe 7.

FastEddieB said:
In the end I think it's clear that where my vehicle was stopped was not a contributing factor in the accident. His car swinging wide crossing into my lane was.
Click to expand...

Yep, you were well on your side of the center line, so you got that going for ya. Plus you were sitting still.
 
We have added dash cams to both my and my wife's vehicles. We have had too many close calls with idiot drivers. If there is an accident, its your word versus theirs. In the year or two since we've had them, they sure have caught some interesting events.
 
FastEddieB said:
Here's a summary of how we caught the guy.

...
Gotcha!

Late yesterday the deputy informed me he had made contact with the owner, who confessed to leaving the scene of the accident and got a citation for the same.
Click to expand...

Had a similar sleuthing project years ago. Except my car was in a parked in a spot and was sideswiped by someone who couldn't back out without making contact and they left without a note.

ID'd the vehicle after much work*, deputy made contact, and it turned out to be the wife of an auto insurance agent. Deputy said she burst into tears and confessed after his door knock.

Police didn't pursue further, as she "was contrite and learned her lesson". o_O

At least her husband paid the claim.



* (Was a large paid lot that required a window sticker. Knowing they would be back again, I measured bumper heights on every dang car daily to find my crease height. Eventually found it on the far side, still with my red paint smear. I had the matching silver transfer on my car.)
 
Years back, my car was hit by a commercial truck backing out of a municipal parking lot. Hard enough to move the rear of my car about 4'. Truck fled. A witness left a note on my windshield with a partial description of the truck, but they weren't close enough to read the writing or get a tag number. I staked out that parking lot at the same time of day, off and on for two weeks. In my case, there wasn't a happy ending. I never found the truck.
 
Salty said:
That just provides incentive to run. There’s no downside.
Click to expand...

Exactly. And if the driver is under the influence, there's a big upside to running, since by the time he's caught DUI can't be proven. A DUI bust can have all sorts of impacts on employment, child custody, security clearance, etc., but a simple hit-&-run not so much.
 
Mahneuvers said:
About 6 months later we received a note charges were dropped b/c the county had more important matters to pursue.
Click to expand...

That would seriously **** me off.

I would be asking for a list of crimes that were also unimportant, like maybe assault and battery.
 
Salty said:
...dui...
Click to expand...
Two years later, same road, 2 miles closer to home, 5:15am, my son was hit head on by a driver going the wrong way down the divided highway. Closure speed at contact was ~100 mph. Paramedics said my son is lucky to be alive. Neither my son or the other driver have any recollection of the accident -- the power of the mind to protect itself from trauma. The other driver doesn't live anywhere around here and apparently has no idea why he was in this section of town at that time of day. I never heard if either accident was alcohol related. In both cases, I assume for privacy reasons, I could only get the name and age of the other driver.
 
JOhnH said:
Also give credit to the TESLA for recording the event. Of course though, the Tesla haters will say that an ICE car could do that too. Probably, but then, why don't then?
Click to expand...

Many do. I prefer my car not to record anything that may incriminate me. I have a dashcam separate from my car. Doesn't require a $$$$$$ Tesla
 
Congrats on a positive outcome.

Which Dash cam do you have to supplement the Tesla cams?
 
FastEddieB said:
I emailed the files to my son-in-law and he used some frame-by-frame video processing software to come up with a full Tennessee tag # which checked back to a 2010 Nissan Altima, pretty consistent with the fleeing car.
Click to expand...

Great ending to this story Eddie! Curious, what software did he use?
 
Congrats! Great job on getting that tracked down.
 
“We used the vlc player. It’s an app that’s usually used to watch video. It has a feature where you can take slow down the frame rate and then take snap shots of each one. When you screen shot the video you can then edit them in different filters. Some of the filter looked blank when we tried to save them. So we used an open source app named greenshot to snip each picture and save them.”
 
FANTASTIC! Love the sleuthing and legwork! Love seeing people being forced to come clean! If he learns a lesson, 100x better!!
 
Quick update…

First, the fellow’s insurance said they would send us a check for $2,200, which was the amount of their initial estimate. When we said that wouldn’t be nearly enough, they said that was an initial payment to get the ball rolling, and once we had a formal estimate they would pay any difference to the body shop. Sure enough, our body shop estimate was over $6,500 higher, and the insurance company paid that immediately. Still waiting on parts and scheduling, not a big deal since the car’s fully drivable as is.

Secondly, the Knox County State Attorney called to confirm our address. They said a court date for the hit and run charge is scheduled for next month and we’d be getting subpoenas in the mail.

Finally, we’re looking into making a “diminished value” claim. Apparently there’s a formula to reflect how much less the car is worth due to damage history. I’ll let you know how that pans out.
 
FastEddieB said:
Finally, we’re looking into making a “diminished value” claim. Apparently there’s a formula to reflect how much less the car is worth due to damage history. I’ll let you know how that pans out.
Click to expand...

Wow, that's quite progressive. Here in aviation the culprit's insurance gave the mechanic a check to eat in whole, for me a pat in the @ss and and a good luck after the FBO mortared my wing and aileron with a Snap-on bomb dive-toss. No diminished value redress to be found within 100 miles of a T-hangar. Maybe one day

*scurries to the aviation wishing well, looks down at the owner-mx category and MOSAIC quarters from 2015*
:D
 
hindsight2020 said:
Wow, that's quite progressive. Here in aviation the culprit's insurance gave the mechanic a check to eat in whole, for me a pat in the @ss and and a good luck after the FBO mortared my wing and aileron with a Snap-on bomb dive-toss. No diminished value redress to be found within 100 miles of a T-hangar. Maybe one day

*scurries to the aviation wishing well, looks down at the owner-mx category and MOSAIC quarters from 2015*
:D
Click to expand...

I hate to say it, but having been at the table for a number of these, this is where an attorney can earn their keep AND get paid by the insurance company. You'd be amazed how good they are at finding all manner of pocket lint and liability that can only be sorted by a stack of dead presidents.
 
Eddie, I’m glad things are coming along for you.

I think it’s interesting that for your YouTube video of the event, all the comments were requests to use your video on other channels. Maybe that means that sideswipe crashes like this are seldom captured the way you did with the Tesla cameras?
 
I assume those channels just search for clips like that to aggregate and then monetize from their compilations. I granted permission across the board - I can’t see any harm from doing so.

My favorite is Wham Bam Teslacam, recommended by a forum member in the other Tesla thread.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top