Been there about 6 years ago, stayed on the side opposite where the airport is. We stayed at the Oyster Bay Beach resort, we were with another couple. At check in we registered, swiped a card, then we were told to pick up our welcome package with the concierge. We went to the desk, they gave us the package and said our concierge would be by shortly, I smelled a rat so we went to our room. I was right, I found out later they were trying to wrangle people into a sales spiel for the time shares. Other than that the hotel was great.
The island is great also, beach was nice, we went to the bar at the end of the runway, big lines when the cruise ships come it, which is pretty much constant, but it was a great experience. Be careful of the jet blasts, I think about 1 a week end up in the hospital, the danger area is pretty well marked. I believe all the 747s going there are retired, but it's still awesome to watch an airliner fly a pattern there. Have fun.