Not in my experience.
Anyway, just for fun I took a look at the paper that was being used on that 'father's manifesto' page. If you actually read the paper, you will find that the author concludes that if you take in to account flying experience, the difference in accident rates becomes statistically insignificant. That's why he only includes one page on his site - because the very next page she describes the complete model she uses. It's either stupidity or dishonesty (well, or both), but given that it says
in the abstract that the differences are not significant, I suspect he's just trusting his readers won't check up on him.
Here's the article, by the way, though I don't believe access is free.