I will never come here on Sunday again. I was in the hold for 3 hours. I cannot believe there was not a mid-air or a bunch of them I have never been so scared in my life in a plane.
It had nothing to do with being Sunday, and everything to do with the crappy weather on Friday and Saturday, which caused the entire universe to try to get in on the same day.
FWIW, out of my three dozen or so Fisk arrivals, there's been at least one on Sunday each year - So probably a dozen - and I have *never* had to hold at all.
I am only hearing the controllers side of things. Is that normal?
Yep. Read the NOTAM, even if you're never planning on going. It's an interesting procedure, and one of the most important parts of it is "SHUT UP!" (Well, it doesn't say that, but you don't talk on the radio, you merely rock your wings to acknowledge.)
The FISK controllers, usually so amazing, were totally screwed up today.
First, they didn't follow the NOTAM, and insisted on one mile in trail, rather than the usual 1/2 mile. This was, of course, impossible with the number of aircraft in the air.
I gave a presentation on how to do the Fisk arrival a week before the show, and in it I included some video of Fisk Approach from last year. This year, I recognized the guy who had been talking on the radio in the video and so I asked him what happened and why they changed the separation. He said it was at the behest of tower, who was getting slammed with arrivals off of other parts of the procedures (turbine/warbird, IFR, and the unpublished demo arrival for example) plus all of the mass arrivals happening on the same day.
They really need to have a better solution than "everybody converge on one point" when the weather constricts the time available for arrivals. It doesn't help that the parallel runway is east of the bigger runway while the arrivals that can more easily use it are coming from the opposite direction.
They go to a mile in trail when one of the runways isn’t accepting arrivals.
Not saying they were as good as previous years but part of it was the tower accepting and then not accepting arrivals on different runways for whatever reasons.
And yeah, I’ve seen them pull it off with only a half mile in trail to a single runway before so I know... it can be done... I know...
That does depend on everyone being really on their game, maintaining 90 knots until they absolutely have to slow down to land, pulling off into the grass as quickly as possible, not making a full pattern when ATC asks for a short approach, etc.
I thought The Green Dot podcast said he was going to make some loud low passes. That was only one low-ish, not all that loud pass.
Good - They needed to open back up for arrivals!
Last year on Sunday morning one of the controllers told a pilot to leave the area, go land somewhere else, get a copy of the NOTAM, read it and try again.
My hero! If you listen to the awful "Cessna 53A" audio, the controller said at one point (when the pilot said he didn't have a copy of the NOTAM) "Well then, I suggest you land somewhere and go get it" and when the pilot whined more and talked them into letting him in, it just went downhill...
So...for future reference, from a traffic perspective, what is the best day to arrive at Air Venture?
Any day that doesn't immediately follow three days of IFR weather.
It also depends on the time of day. Sunday afternoon is often fairly busy, but if you get to Ripon at 7:30 PM, they sometimes tell you to just fly it on in at full speed if there isn't anyone in front of you. They'll start asking if anyone is inbound on the radio and such.
Bryan showed me a similar picture. My question to him was, do all those people still have their transponders on? NOTAM says to switch them to standby. Do traffic targets on ads-b still show N-numbers if the transponder is on standby, or are there that many people that don't read and/or abide by the NOTAM?
For the last couple of years, the NOTAM has said to keep transponders on if you have ADS-B. Might as well get the new tech working, since it's the most useful time to have it!
So I just found out I have to be in St Paul next monday morning. Would it be worth being at the show Friday and Saturday or is it basically already over then?
I always tell people that if they only have one day to do it, Saturday is the best. They tend to have lots of military hardware flying during the day, and there's the big night airshow at night.
Sunday is kind of boring, though, except if you want to watch departures. It's mostly locals (non-pilots) in the crowd that day, most of the exhibitors are packing up, the airshow is shortened to allow for all of the departures, and it kinda turns into a ghost town by afternoon.
so for realz, how do I go about reserving either camping OR a local hotel? are there local hotels so close u can walk over? 2 years in a row I should'a gone but didn't.
Only two hotels within walking distance (Hilton and Super 8) and they're probably both booked for next year already. But camping is really the ultimate Oshkosh experience, and I highly recommend it. No reservations required.
So the head wind that kicked my tail going up was kinder going home. Wheels up this morning at 0752, landed 1127. The little Cherokee 140 did well. Best part is OSH wanted turns to 150 coming off 36L before tower. Got to kick her over hard right climbing turn.
That's not "tower wants", that's right in the NOTAM. Otherwise you'd be flying right up into the 9/27 arrivals and departures.
EAA forgot to send it out on OSHALERT too if they have weather coming. That or the service isn’t working right today.
Probably because a billion people who aren't at the show are on it.
"For your safety...."
BS. It's the EAA. They just don't want your money to get wet.
They automatically cancel for lightning within 15 miles. Might have something to do with all of the pyro and fireworks, or the tens of thousands of people standing outside under metal objects. But they made the right call.
Flying your own plane into OSH and camping in the North 40 is the ONLY way to do it.
Plan it properly the first time and you will never do it any other way after that...until you're so old your wheelchair won't fit in the Mooney. Then maybe a hotel.
Having done both, I now camp sans airplane in Scholler. I used to look down upon the ground pounders who didn't have an airplane to camp with, but Scholler has better facilities, you can have campfires, and I don't have to worry about gross weight when packing.
This year, I lucked out and was able to borrow a friend's travel trailer. THAT is the "only" way to do it.
That said, every pilot should camp with their airplane at least once. I just hope your once isn't like my last time camping with the airplane, where I ended up calling my wife at 3 AM to just come and take me home because my semi-destroyed tent was lying on top of me and I was lying in three inches of rainwater.
In any case, camping somewhere on the field is the way to go. You get to live and breathe aviation 24x7. It is absolutely the best experience for aviation lovers to have.
I think the biggest difference for me staying at the dorm vs camping with the airplane is I felt more like a tourist and not really a participant at Oshkosh.
This is why I said camping on the field is the way to go. It really is different.
Another solution to that is an RV in Scholler. Less problems with night and overnight activities, but you don’t get to fly in.
Technically there are companies that will pre-deliver an RV to Scholler, and you could fly in and park in GA Parking, and walk/tram to your home away from home in Scholler, also.
Yes. RV on site is the most comfortable way to go, and if you can do that and still fly in, it's even better!
This year was my first RV, but because of the traffic debacles, we left the plane at home. First time I haven't flown in to Oshkosh in a LONG time.