NA -- What is your favorite war movie?

I find Sergeant York eminently rewatchable - if somewhat campy.

Trailer:


It appears the entire movie is up on YouTube, legitimately or otherwise.
 
I watched Sergeant York not long ago, as well as All Quiet on the Western Front. I re-watched The Blue Max a couple of years ago. Liked them all.
 
Nope. Google Sgt Schultz.

Hogan's Heroes was the T.V. version of Stalag 17. I made my comment because this thread is about war MOVIES, not because Sgt. Schultz was not on Hogan's Heroes. That was my in-artfully drafted point.
 
American Revolution: The Patriot.
Civil War: Gettysburg, Cold Mountain, Lincoln.
WWI: The Lost Batallion.
WW II: Band of Brothers, SPR, Schindler's List, Escape from Sobibor. There are so many good ones that I won't miss if I'm flipping through, though.

Vietnam: We Were Soldiers, Platoon, FMJ. I liked Hamburger Hill at the time, but after some good movies were done it's hard to consider that one well made. I liked the earlier seasons of Tour of Duty even though when I break out the DVDs I watch them all from start to finish. I've never seen China Beach and have always wondered if it's any good.
 
[QUOTE="Gerhardt, post: 2171957, I've never seen China Beach and have always wondered if it's any good.[/QUOTE]

Saw them all, good show and enjoyed it.
 
Das Boot

We Were Soldiers

Paths of Glory

Full Metal Jacket

We Were Soldiers

Run Silent, Run Deep

Gardens of Stone

I love The Cain Mutiny, but being a complete work of fiction, I can't include it with the rest.
 
Das Boot
Empire of the Sun
Threads
Red Dawn (original)
Battle of Britain
 
[QUOTE="Gerhardt, post: 2171957, I've never seen China Beach and have always wondered if it's any good.

Saw them all, good show and enjoyed it.[/QUOTE]

I had a thing...wait, have a thing, for Dana Delaney...
 
Guns of Navarone
Where Eagles Dare
Kelly's Heroes
Bridge on the River Kwai
 
How has no one mentioned blackhawk down? One of my all time favorites.
 
My favorite war movies tend to be anti-war movies, like:

Paths of Glory
Das Boot
Thin Red Line
Enemy at the Gates
 
I would agree with that. From our standpoint, the war was never about Vietnam, it was about stopping Soviet progression in Southeast Asia. In the end, that never played out since Vietnam actually had no interest in having a direct Soviet presence within the country, and the Soviets at the time were more focused on Western Europe, not Southeast Asia. One could make the argument that our support of the South Vietnamese was humanitarian in nature. Vietnam was, and to some extent still is, almost two separate countries with respect to the North and the South. The Southern Vietnamese were keenly interested in having our support to prevent the North from taking them over, cutting off their artistic and cultural presence, which is what happened for about a twenty year period until the government opened up the country again. Ironically, however, Ho Chi Minh, who was a southerner, opted to side with the North in the very early years of the conflict as he felt the North was most effective way to oust the French.

Sitting here today, Vietnam has mostly disposed of its government held corporate assets to private investors, and is less socialist than we are. They are also starting to compete with China for industrial exports. Neither Karl Marx nor Bernie Sanders would approve of their implementation of communism.
Ho was educated in France. He was a nationalist not a communist and wrote to Harry Truman saying he really admired Thomas Jefferson. After ww2 he expected the French to get out and they would run their own country. Not so. The French had rubber plantations, etc. refused to leave and got their ass handed to them. When we would not assist him he turned to the communists to help arm him. Big commie scare at the time which we used to intervene. We'd also got our ass handed to us. Dumb war
 
Last edited:
Ho was educated in France. He wasn't nationalist not a communist and wrote to Harry Truman saying he really admired Thomas Jefferson. After ww2 he expected the French to get out and they would run their own country. Not so. The French had rubber plantations, etc. refused to leave and got their ass handed to them. When we would not assist him he turned to the communists to help arm him. Big commie scare at the time which we used to intervene. We'd also got our ass handed to us. Dumb war

That is correct.
 
And no one mentioned The Final Countdown. Sitting in the theater in 1980 with the first scene of the Tomcat taking off...priceless!
 
Final Countdown - I saw it in a theater in Newport News,. A lot of guys in the audience were from the Nimitz and had been extras. They were laughing every time they saw someone they knew. It was fun.
 
And no one mentioned The Final Countdown. Sitting in the theater in 1980 with the first scene of the Tomcat taking off...priceless!

Next time you watch that movie, there is a scene where an F-14 performs a split-s to avoid a Zero. Notice how low the pull-out is - the F-14 is at a pretty high AOA and the exhaust disturbs the surface of the ocean. Someone probably spooked himself and his backseater very badly in that scene...

<Edit> I just re-watched that scene. It is more of a badly dished low speed roll than a Spit-S, but the end result is the same...
 
Last edited:
An interesting movie for date-night: "Heaven Knows, Mr. Allison". Deborah Kerr makes a pretty hot nun.
 
To the above add 'Air Force'.
 
"Three Kings" is OK for a rental. Not exactly a war movie as much as a movie that's set in a war.
 
Nobody's yet started the Cold War ones...

Hunt for Red October
I liked the Cold War movies as a kid, which is perhaps a little warped; Fail Safe, Seven Days in May, Dr. Strangelove... The only one I've seen as an adult is Dr. Strangelove. I still like that one. I wonder how the others would hold up now.
 
Not a declared war, but "The Sea Hawk" is swashbuckling fun. The English underdogs vs. the evil Spanish. (Stand-ins for Nazi Germany.)
 
Then there is "Action in the North Atlantic" - another WW-II propaganda film that totally slaughters reality.
 
Did anyone add Canadian Bacon and/or South Park - The Movie?

Two good wars against those Canadians and their socialist ways.
 
Back
Top