Okay, so I started writing this, it probably qualifies as my longest post to date - but oh well; stream of consciousness does that; get comfortable...
Hi, Becky: my two and half cents is below. As is said in other arenas, 'take what you like, and leave the rest.' Please note that I'm not a therapist, and am only going from what's been written here - without hearing your husband's position directly, it's hard to know what the exact best path is.
Fair warning to anyone turned off by "touchy-feely" reading; there may be some of that in here - deal with it...
My observations are around communication, change and a little bit of compromise.
As I'm reading your postings, an image kept coming into my head, of a photo from our wedding album. The photographer had taken our wedding bands and flowers, and arranged the rings as intersecting circles - not one covering the exact same space as the other, and not one wholly enclosed within the other. Reminds me that while we're partners in our marriage, we're both still individuals as well. It's part of what keeps things interesting, and I think things would get pretty boring if that weren't the case.
The bugaboo sometimes comes in when the amount of that intersection starts changing - how to keep a balance when new activities enter the picture. Your last post provided some useful points and mileposts. We don't have any (human) children (cats are self-cleaning and don't require college funds), but your comments about raising them sounded like it was quite the experience, maybe sometimes a feeling of 'you and husband' vs. 'the kids'. I'm just guessing that that circle intersection got pretty large at points of that process, and while it would certainly make you stronger, it may not have allowed for much opportunity for either of you to, well, be 'just you', because everything is all about the kids then.
Piecing together your posts, it sounds like your husband might have gotten interested in flying right about the time you launched the younger child (18-20-ish age range); a reasonable time to evaluate and think about what to do to fill all of that free time you suddenly have
So, the circle intersection gets a bit smaller as new hobbies are discovered. And, depending on your position, you're either OK with it (if you're the one who's discovering the new hobby, and find it to your liking), or not (if you're on the other side, and feel that you're 'losing out' to this new hobby).
You mentioned that this is a second marriage, and that both of you feel you were too accommodating in your first marriages; I have no way of knowing the true story, but it sounds like both of you may be digging in your heels and not want to compromise based on some of that history - you don't want the change that you feel has been imposed on you, so the response is , to undo the change (i.e., husband not fly); your husband, having finally gotten the opportunity to find something that he enjoys and has a sense of considerable personal accomplishment (having started your training a while ago, I'm sure you understand what it takes to not only start private pilot training, to say nothing of completing it with ticket in hand), is concerned about falling back into the 'accommodating' mode by being asked to stop doing what he's worked to achieve to date. If the conversations to this point have consistently been focused around asking him to stop flying, I can see why the response may be to not discuss it; it will be seen as "same old conversation, I'm not giving this up no matter what she says....." heels dig in, and the door shuts closed.
I've only mentioned flying a little bit so far because I don't think it's about flying specifically; I think you could put almost any new hobby or interest in this same situation. I think the key success factor on this will come from some compromise and balance on this, and I think you get that as well. Not knowing your husband's specific actions, I can only offer input on what I see in your posts, which would focus on your reactions to things. Please note that I'm not saying that you have to be the only one to make a compromise or two just because more words are placed in that direction; it's just because we haven't heard your husband's side, so I can't comment on it.
As a pilot, I would agree with many of the other posters here, in that stopping flying altogether would not be realistic. I chose aviation as a hobby to try something new and scratch a long-dormant itch; and went from being quite scared before my first intro flight, to hooked by the time we landed. It was just like a light switch, and to be asked to turn it off entirely after it's been flipped on, with all the work, sweat and tears expended to get to where I am so far (private pilot with instrument rating)...... I'll put it this way: I have a couple of college degrees that were no small feat to obtain; but I value that plastic card from the FAA in my wallet almost as highly as I do those framed pieces of paper, because of what it represents to me; an accomplishment that I chose to undertake, a journey that many others along the way have started but not completed, but I can stand up at the end of the day and say, 'I am a pilot.' I value it all the more when I think of people I've met who started their training, but were derailed at some point due to various factors (family, money, time, fill in the blank); their stories of training all seem to end with a sigh of regret at not finishing - and a request to fly vicariously through me, which I don't mind at all. Guess it's good it was a vicarious flying; on our first trip to the Bahamas, we'd have been way over weight and balance trying to fit everybody in the Skylane in person
In my case, once my husband saw I was serious about going this route, he started to get curious about flying, but not an outright fan in the beginning, just a few pieces at first - initial step was wanting to learn to read maps to help out, but not fly; then to 'just a few lessons, in case I need to land in an emergency', but not fly as PIC; then the competitive streak set in, and it was off to the races; we kept our flight instructor very busy that summer
If he hadn't been curious about flying, would I have stopped? I would probably say no; that sense of personal accomplishment for me was pretty significant, and I'm the type that wants to finish what she starts, so I would still fly. If he had been not just 'not curious', but adamantly opposed to my flying, would I have stopped? Probably yes, but it would have left me feeling that I 'got walked over', and made a very unbalanced accommodation in that partnership.
But before hanging up the wings, I think I certainly would have tried to find out what the reason was for the opposition, and come up with ways to include him in some aspect of aviation so he can get a sense of how important it is to me, and have him share my newfound happiness in some way. If , after discussion and having alternatives for inclusion shot down, the final reason came down to "I just don't want you to fly, because I don't want things to change, and I want you to spend all of your time with me", then I would start to feel pretty ticked off - it would feel like he's not at all interested in what makes me happy, and that the marriage is all about his comfort rather than a balance for both of us. And if that's the case, we've entered a whole new set of discussions, most likely ending with legal counsel on both sides.
And then the wings would come back down off of the shelf
(OK, at this point, y'all might be interested to know that I've taken a break in writing, gone down to have dinner and come back up to the computer - so I guess it's time to wrap this up....)
So a few things to consider in short:
- First; I think you'll need to get comfortable with the idea that flying is in your world for now. It is a change that is unlikely to be reversed, regardless of how you may choose to dig in the heels. The key is how to make at least some of it part of that circle intersection between the two of you, rather than being completely in his 'outer segment'.
- Confirm that you are rock-solid convinced that you will be unable to get in a plane due to the physical sensations. I know you've said before that flying for you is a non-starter, but I only ask because of a couple of things in your posts give me some pause as to whether it's permanently, absolutely non-changeable: that you did start your own flying at some point, that you initially noted that you got out of it due to expense and your friends' accident (i.e., not a physical sensation thing at the time; and that accident can be a huge mental barrier to overcome, the feeling that you may fall out of the sky at some point too.... but is not insurmountable), that you're not so uncomfortable in larger planes (might a different plane make a difference? Not sure what planes your husband is currently renting, but hopping around for currency in the pattern and practice area in a Cessna 152 is a very different experience than a cross-country flight in (to me) the greater comfort of a Cessna 182). My only input would be to be real honest with yourself on this one; it will be easy to jump to "I just can't do it" because it's a comfortable response, but getting to the root of 'why' will make a big difference. Someone else mentioned that this may be a medical issue; I'm not a physician, but if the sensation problem is apparent in other situations (I think you mentioned carnival rides or roller coasters somewhere, but I could be misremembering things), it's worth checking out.
- If you can confirm the above (rock-solid no way to get in the plane, physical issue that is uncorrectable, let's say),consider asking your husband to brainstorm with you about ways you can get involved with aviation aside from stepping in the plane. Just as you may be hanging in the 'no fly no way' camp, he may be looking around and seeing that the predominant way non-pilot spouses participate in aviation is to get in the plane for a ride, so it's the solution he's focusing on; I know how my husband can certainly be quick to focus on one solution, while not always thinking through alternatives. But that's not necessarily the only solution; get creative here! Other forms of participation could be structured (e.g., being part of the ground crew on Angel Flights, if your time permits; no flying on your part (some driving perhaps), but you're in some sync with the aviation community), or less structured (go out to the airport sometime when he's practicing, have a seat on the bench, watch the takeoffs and landings, hold up rating cards
, and get to know the folks on the field a bit - again, a way to get introduced into the community without needing to be behind the yoke yourself), or something in between. The key is that you're expressing a interest in this part of his world and taking the steps to become a bit more involved, rather than giving a vibe that you wish it would simply disappear.
- Key to that conversation above is that your husband knows that you're not asking him to give up flying entirely (again, you need to be really OK with that, it will keep that communication door open), and that as a pilot who will be more in tune with the opportunities in aviation, that you value his input to find ways to share in this new activity 1) while you work up to getting in the plane at some point, or 2) even though you're physically unable to fly in small planes, whichever applies.
As to your husband's part in this; if he sees that you're trying to meet him partway on this, it might be reasonable for him to meet you partway too, perhaps on the time aspect - not a set limit of 'X' hours and no more, but to get that balance of 'ground time' with you as well as time in the air . You may be able to mix it up a bit - meet him for a meal after he's been flying, ask how things went - if there's one thing pilots never run out of, it's flying stories
And you may find that he's not quite as grumpy with the ground time if he at least knows that you're not asking him to give up everything, and that you're actively looking to get involved in a way that's possible for you.
From what you've written, it sounds like you have a solid marriage in other areas, and can communicate on other subjects just fine, which is the best thing. I do believe aviation can be a successful area for both of you as well, with a little compromise and creativity. And it's a good conversation to have as a precursor for when YOU get 'bitten' with the bug for a hobby that you're gaga about, that the hubby just can't understand and get into initially - he may not have an interest board to take it to, so lots of good notes here
Best of luck, Leslie